Afghan elections become another western imposed process: senior research fellow on Afghanistan & Pakistan issues

Afghan elections become another western imposed process: senior research fellow on Afghanistan & Pakistan issues

The United States, Sept. 23 / Trend , N.Bogdanova/

Interview with Senior Research Fellow on Afghanistan and Pakistan issues, based Washington DC Matthew P. Dearing, who has served in the recent years on the U.S. Marine Corps, current the Research Associate of Program for Culture & Conflict Studies of Naval Postgraduate School.

Trend : Is it possible that the massive riots and protest actions against results of the president election in Afghanistan can put the legitimacy of the whole process under suspicion? Especially if the presidency of Karzai is confirmed how will that influence the image of Taliban?

Matthew P. Dearing: The elections were never really considered legitimate by the majority of Afghans. Many in the urban areas voted and held a general perception that the elections had some semblance of legitimacy, but the great majority of rural, village Afghans (which compose nearly 80 percent of the population) had little interest in the election process, which they perceived as an international scam to legitimize a corrupt regime that they hardly ever see. Elections, while a noble endeavor, are unfortunately another western imposed process that has not been met with proper institutional mechanisms needed to support the democratic initiative. Kabul does not have the power, influence or structural capacity to represent itself outside the urban and provincial capitals, thus few Afghans experience the presence of central government. Those times Afghans do experience the government, it is unfortunately when being shaken down by National Police or facing a defunct judiciary that awards justice to the wealthy and powerful. Karzai will face significant problems as his election will not be seen as legitimate. How Abdullah reacts and whether he organizes a resistance effort will be a interesting to watch. I suspect intense efforts are underway by Afghans and international governments to convince Abdullah to support Karzai.

Q: A number of new strategies to rebuilt stability in Afghanistan are currently been use in the country. What were the problems of previous strategies and what should be done now?

A: Part of the problem has been pushing the reach of the central government without an equally intense effort at building capacity at the local level. Some strategies focused on local development efforts like the National Solidarity Program, were very successful but were given limited funding. NSP projects were actually protected by local villagers and subsequently
went untargeted by Taliban insurgents, whereas many projects emanating from international forces via Provincial Reconstruction Teams have been highly targeted. The key to successful reconstruction in Afghanistan is to focus development on the local level and merge those with existing provincial level infrastructure projects.

Q: It is believed that the Taliban are fighting against foreign forces in Afghanistan, but until 1996 they were fighting against local government. Do you believe that if the foreign forces are out of the country then Taliban will weaken their activity?

A: If foreign forces leave Afghanistan; a civil war will break out. The only structure preventing warlords, tribes and clans from fighting each other is the presence of a perceived external enemy - the west, i.e. the US. The Kabul government would certainly fall were international forces to leave.

The city would be divided into sectarian sections - Hazara, Uzbek, Tajik, Pashtun as was the case in 1996. Pakistan would provide support to Pashtun elements, likely a Taliban alliance led by either Mullah Omar or Berader. Civilian deaths would be in the hundreds of thousands...it would be a disaster. While our presence in Afghanistan is not a perfect solution, it is much better than a complete withdrawal, which would throw the country into complete chaos.

Q: Do you believe that Afghan Taliban and Pakistani Taliban are the same group, or there are two separate ones?

A: These are two separate groups with separate goals and aspirations. In general, the Afghan Taliban is focused on driving US forces and western influence out of Afghanistan and ensuring the Afghan government is a legitimate Islamic government. In general, Pakistani Taliban are supportive of the US cause but are more focused on what they see as a corrupt and
illegitimate civilian government in Pakistan. They have been inspired by the rebellion in Afghanistan and distraught by the alignment between the US and Pakistan that developed since Musharraf gave in to US demands post-9/11. There are many different factions within each of these groups that hold a variety of aspirations and motivations. Thus, one should be careful when they say the Taliban want this or that - one needs to distinguish which Taliban (Hezbi-i-Islami, Haqqani Network, Torra Bora Group, Quetta Shura, TTP, TNSM, etc.). While all of these can be placed under one umbrella or the other, they all have different locally and regionally focused imperatives.

CNPC branch in Turkmenistan opens tender provision of supervision services
CNPC branch in Turkmenistan opens tender provision of supervision services
Public sector of Turkmenistan increases production volumes
Public sector of Turkmenistan increases production volumes
Turkmenistan to participate in implementation of container line between Russia, Iran
Turkmenistan to participate in implementation of container line between Russia, Iran
Loading Bars
Latest
Armenia refuses to participate in event to resume dialogue with Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan’s AzerGold company opens tender to buy services
Turkey’s export of cars to Kyrgyzstan increases
Diversification of economy may increase Azerbaijan's credit rating - Unicapital
Kazakhstan, Malaysia eye closer co-op within Islamic Organization for Food Security
Georgia opens regional beekeeping center via support of Chezch investors
CNPC branch in Turkmenistan opens tender provision of supervision services
Moderna CEO says world faces 2022 COVID vaccine production surplus
E-auction for right to explore and produce hydrocarbons wraps up in Kazakhstan
Azerbaijan eyes to expand pomegranate export in 2021
Very ambitious reforms carried out in energy sector of Georgia - deputy minister
Azerbaijan, Hungary agree to cooperate in developing e-government
Uzbekistan remains largest importer of Kazakh wheat
United Airlines gets summer ready; to add over 480 flights to U.S. schedule
Israel's Health Ministry warns against travel to seven countries
Ambassador of Georgia to Ukraine returns to his duties
Georgia's import of tubes, pipes, hollow profiles from Turkey decreases
Georgia's Geostat reveals volume of ferroalloys exported to Turkey
Azerbaijan, Turkey to exchange experience on capital markets dev't
Georgia sees increase in volume of new mortgages - TBC Capital
Port of Baku may be transferred to private management - Director-General
Turkey reveals volume of cargo shipped through ports since early 2021
Kazakhstan suspends trade, economic co-op agreement with Croatia
Georgia can become one of 25 largest blueberry exporters in world
Public sector of Turkmenistan increases production volumes
Kazakhstan reveals physical volume of GDP for 2020
Azerbaijan announces date for export of domestic cars to Ukraine
Georgia's imports of medical products from Turkey down
Turkmenistan to participate in implementation of container line between Russia, Iran
Azerbaijan publishes data on number of vaccinated citizens for Apr. 23
Azerbaijani president appoints temporary Health Minister
IFC to provide assistance to Georgia in field of investment
Georgia sees increase in import of vehicles from Turkey
TAP implementing €800,000 worth program to reduce marine litter
Georgian exports of knitwear to Turkey up
Nar launches “Reading hour” Project for schoolchildren
Total volume of bank deposits of Azerbaijani population slightly decreases
Azerbaijan confirms 1,809 more COVID-19 cases, 2,191 recoveries
Georgia joins European Union's Eurodesk network
AmEx profit beats on over $1 bln reserve release boost
Azerbaijani president signs decree on dismissal of Health Minister
Azerbaijan publishes 1Q2021 data on gas exports to Italy
Businesses in Georgia to begin recovery in 2H2021 - Banking Association of Georgia
Lending to public organizations in Azerbaijan drops
Uzbekistan considers co-op with Caspian states as priority direction of foreign policy strategy
Azerbaijan cooperates with leading countries in robotics development - ministry
CNPC subsidiary opens tender in Turkmenistan for purchase of electrical materials
Deutsche Bank supports its Kazakhstan-based partner banks amid COVID-19 crisis
Turkey’s support of Georgia’s integration into NATO - crucial - Georgian FM
Azerbaijan shares data on bank deposits in foreign currency
Uzbekistan, US talk strategic partnership prospects
Panasonic to buy U.S. supply-chain software firm Blue Yonder for $7.1 bln
Iran's TPO expects trade growth
Germany’s biased attempt to undermine Azerbaijan - blatant hypocrisy - Azerbaijani political analyst
Kazakhstan-Romania trade plummets
Georgia sees surge in labor market
China-Europe Rail Transit Corridor to pass through Iran - RAI
Bank of Russia increases key rate to 5% per annum
N. Macedonia soon to ink deal for pipeline to get Azerbaijani gas
Azerbaijan sees annual decrease in deposits of local banks
Azerbaijan shares data on cotton sown area
Turkmenistan's Turkmenstandartlary opens tender for purchase of testing gas meters samples
SOCAR buys 3 oil tankers from Greek maritime corporation - sources
Iran's Mercantile Exchange to offer cars for sale
Azerbaijan's ASCO to engage tanker insurance services via tender
More joint border crossings could boost Iran-Pakistan trade ties - Chamber of Commerce
Iran's exports to Africa down
Azerbaijan hopes US Administration will not make historical mistake - Assistant to president
Iran's priority to provide COVID-19 vaccine from abroad than wait for domestic one - official
Turkey’s export of chemicals to US surges
Uzbek-Korean JV opens tender for compressors spares
Cargo turnover at Turkish Antalya Airport declines for 1Q2021
Students of Baku Higher Oil School become winners of ‘Enactus Azerbaijan Spring School’ project
Turkey discloses number of companies with Uzbek capital since early 2021
Iran receives new batch of Russian 'Sputnik V' COVID-19 vaccine
Azerbaijani IT company expands its range of solutions through int'l co-op
SpaceX rocketship launches 4 astronauts on NASA mission to space station
Turkey discloses number of Gemlik port-received ships in 2M2021
Decrease in bank lending observed in Baku and Azerbaijani districts
France should abandon OSCE MG co-chairmanship - French Senate member
Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan discuss issuing visas to drivers
TCO unveils timeframe plans for annual maintenance turnaround at Kazakhstan’s Tengiz
Azerbaijan discloses national team at Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup
Defeat in Second Karabakh War - hard psychological point for Armenia, says Russian analyst
Germany ready to take part in gas production expansion projects in Kazakhstan
Uzbekistan's gold and foreign exchange reserves keep declining
Share of non-budgetary organizations in compulsory social insurance receipts increases in Azerbaijan
TOP-10 importers of Azerbaijani oil in 1Q2021
Uzbekistan’s volume of received cross-border transfers increases
Georgian reveals volume of funds spent on utility bill subsidy
Georgia, Ukraine to issue electronic permits for int'l cargo transport
Kazakhstan decreases production of raw sulfur over 1Q2021
Uzbekistan eyes exporting fresh and dried fruit, vegetable products to Latvia
Georgia increases imports of cars from Turkey
International Forum on Attracting Investment in Oil, Gas Industry of Turkmenistan select sponsor
JOCAP details plans for platform around Oil Rocks
Russia records another 8,840 coronavirus cases
JOCAP updates on progress in operations of PLBH for Absheron project
Turkey reduces exports of grain, legumes to Turkmenistan
Azerbaijan's State Committee on Property Issues to hold auction for state properties
All news