The Cold War: Who really won and who really lost?

The Cold War: Who really won and who really lost?

By Claude Salhani- Trend

Recent tensions between Washington and Moscow over Russia's actions in Ukraine and the reclaiming of Crimea is raising the specter of the Cold War. Before the situation reverts back to the ways of the old days and relations reach the freezing point, it might be worth looking back to see how we have reached this point, and perhaps learn from history.

As you ponder that question, at the same time think of the billions of dollars that are spent each year maintaining the various elements that makes up what is referred to in the United States as the Intelligence Community (IC). In return for all this taxpayer's money being spent and as a result of their intelligence gathering, the agencies are meant to be able to foretell and forewarn policy makers of major political events and how those events may affect national security.

Yet in spite of all available resources the U.S. intelligence community failed to predict two events of gargantuan proportions and importance: the fall of the Berlin Wall along with the demise of communism, and some years later the resurgence of Russia as a major player in global politics.

The combined budget of the U.S. intelligence community for the year 2014 is $45.225 billion.
The exact numbers of people involved is a closely guarded secret as deep cover agents may be known only to their handlers, the agents back in the U.S. or perhaps overseas to whom these spies report, but one U.S. government source places the number at about 200,000.
The IC is composed of no fewer than 17 different agencies, each one operating independently from the other. Each member agency operates under its own directive.
The most known is the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). Its primary mission is to collect, analyze, evaluate, and disseminate foreign intelligence. This intelligence is intended to help government policy makers in making national security and defense decisions. The CIA is not meant to make policy recommendations.

Then there is the Department of Energy, Office of Intelligence and Counterintelligence. The DOE is responsible for U.S. energy policy and nuclear safety. They provide timely technical intelligence analysis on all aspects of foreign nuclear weapons, nuclear materials and energy issues worldwide.

We have the Department of Homeland Security, Intelligence and Analysis. Formed after the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the U.S., their mission is to equip the Homeland Security Enterprise with the intelligence and information it needs to keep the Homeland safe, secure, and resilient.

The Department of State, Intelligence and Research (DOS) handles intelligence analysis, policy, and coordination of intelligence activities in support of diplomacy. They provide a wide range of intelligence support to the Secretary of State and other policymakers, ambassadors, special negotiators, country directors and desk officers. The DOS is the Secretary of State's principal adviser on all intelligence matters.

The Department of Treasury, Office of Intelligence and Analysis advises policymakers on domestic and international financial, monetary, economic, trade and tax policy and provide focused intelligence support to Treasury officials.

The Defense Intelligence Agency, or DIA, is one of four major intelligence agencies that along with the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency, the National Reconnaissance Office and the National Security Agency make up the Department of Defense. Those are not to be confused with the U.S. Air Force, Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance, U.S. Army, Army Military Intelligence; U.S. Coast Guard, Coast Guard Intelligence; U.S. Marine Corps, Marine Corps Intelligence Activity, U.S. Navy, Naval Intelligence.

There is also the Drug Enforcement Administration, DEA, responsible for enforcing federal controlled substances laws and regulations.

The Federal Bureau of Investigation is an intelligence and law enforcement agency tasked with understanding threats to national security and penetrating national, as well as transnational, networks that wish to and are capable of harming the U.S. They focus on terrorist organizations, foreign intelligence services, weapons proliferators, and criminal enterprises. Initially the FBI was not meant to operate overseas, but was restricted to operating in the United States. Intelligence gathering, espionage and counterespionage were meant to be the domain of the CIA but after 9/11 many things changed and the FBI began opening up bureaus overseas.

And last, but by no means least, is the Office of the Director of National Intelligence. The ODNI was established in 2004 to manage the extensive efforts of the IC. The Director of National Intelligence (DNI) heads up the ODNI and serves as the principal advisor to the president, the National Security Council, and the Homeland Security Council. The DNI also coordinates intelligence matters related to the Department of Defense.
When the Berlin Wall fell and communism went bankrupt and withered away, a number of foreign policy experts in the U.S. and Europe -this analyst included - said it would be a tragic mistake to treat Russia as a defeated superpower. Rather, the belief was that Russia should be hailed as one of the nations who had defeated communism.
While Bush, pere, (also knows as Bush 41, the 41st president) was careful not to shove the Soviet defeat in their face, the same cannot be said of the arrogant son, Bush 43, (also known as the Mini Shrub). He took the U.S. into two wars in what used to be Soviet hunting grounds.

"Ignoring the lessons of history, dominant voices in the West couldn't resist humiliating Russia as a defeated superpower and pushing NATOs frontiers ever closer to the former enemy. This, in turn, fed long-held Russian fears of encirclement," writes Arnaud de Borchgrave, one of the sharpest minds and top political analyst and former Newsweek chief correspondent.
De Borchgrave says of Russian President Vladimir Putin, "Russia's new Czar, a former KGB colonel in East Germany during the tail end of the Cold War, was biding his time to get even with the American superpower. Putin's decision to reintegrate Crimea in mother Russia -- once handed by Nikita Khrushchev to Ukraine at the end of a long liquid evening--was a bold move regarded by most Russians as long overdue."

The U.S. and the West badly played their cards - which they dealt themselves - and in the process played themselves into a corner.

First, a large part of Europe depends on Russian gas to heat homes, offices and factories. Second, the U.S. is counting on Russia to help the U.S. military pullout from Afghanistan when it happens later this year. The shortest route, through Pakistan and to the Gulf is unsafe and cannot be secured. Russia is offering safe passage through its territory to a Baltic port - for a price, of course. And finally, the U.S. depends on Russia to get its astronauts to/from the International Space Station, as it no longer has any working spacecraft.

Given the above facts places the whole notion of who won and who lost the Cold War in a new light. Does it not?
Claude Salhani is senior editor at Trend Agency in Baku and a political analyst specializing in the Middle East, Central Asia and terrorism. You can follow him on Twitter @claudesalhani

Funds allocated for creation of heat supply system in Azerbaijan’s Shusha
Funds allocated for creation of heat supply system in Azerbaijan’s Shusha
Azerbaijan's MoD shares video about Shusha - cultural capital of Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan's MoD shares video about Shusha - cultural capital of Azerbaijan
Cult of personality of Garegin Nzhdeh in Armenia can be compared with that of Hitler in Nazi Germany – Russian analyst
Cult of personality of Garegin Nzhdeh in Armenia can be compared with that of Hitler in Nazi Germany – Russian analyst
Loading Bars
Funds allocated for creation of heat supply system in Azerbaijan’s Shusha
France’s import of steel from Turkey up
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on May 9
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry places medium-term bonds on auction
Cotton spinning factory of Turkmenistan’s Lebap region names production data
Chevron should remain cautious in further increasing oil & gas production
Azerbaijan to continue online lessons in 10th-11th grades, minister says
Foreign shipping lines expected to return to Iran
Austria increases import of steel from Turkey
Fars Province to be connected to north-east and south-east of Iran via railway line
1Q2021 value of operations via interbank national settlements system in Azerbaijan down
United Arab Bank turns around with Dh10.2 million net profit
Azerbaijan's MoD shares video about Shusha - cultural capital of Azerbaijan
New jobs created in Iran's Ardabil Province
Turkmenistan's Turkmengas opens tender for overhaul of gas turbine engines
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price falls
World Cup in Baku became one of my favorite competitions - Azerbaijani gymnast (PHOTO)
Khazar Consortium opens tender for purchase of controller
Value of Iran's import of Turkish steel in 4M2021 grows
Russia’s coronavirus reproduction rate remains below 1
Azerbaijan sets up new military units in liberated lands (PHOTO)
Kazakhstan increases exports to UAE
Best moments of second day of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku (PHOTO)
Kazakh gymnast shares impressions of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup taking place in Baku
Cult of personality of Garegin Nzhdeh in Armenia can be compared with that of Hitler in Nazi Germany – Russian analyst
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 8
EU sceptical on vaccine waiver, but ready to discuss proposal
Azerbaijan confirms 649 more COVID-19 cases, 1,720 recoveries
Iran declares details of exports from Ardabil Province
Uzbekistan projects volume of direct foreign investments for 2021
Exports via Iran's Sistan and Baluchestan Province up
Turkey's 4M2021 export of steel to Georgia surges in value
China boosts import of Azerbaijani products y-o-y
Azerbaijan's Central Bank unveils data on foreign exchange transactions over March 2021
Azerbaijani Ro-Pax type ferry reaches Kazakh port of Kuryk (PHOTO)
G-7 countries back Taiwan's observer status in World Health Assembly
Lack of minefield maps delays mine clearance - Trend TV
Uzbekistan’s 1Q2021 cars export revealed
Results of Azerbaijani gymnasts’ performance in exercises with clubs, ribbons as part of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku (PHOTO)
Turkish Energy Ministry prolongs oil, gas exploration licenses for several companies
Azerbaijani president displayed successful strategy on battlefield and in media - two tactics of Great Victory
Turkmenistan sees active dev't of cotton industry
Latvia reveals main economic indicators of bilateral cooperation with Georgia
Iran discloses number of restored mines in South Khorasan Province
Germany's confirmed coronavirus cases rise by 15,685
Azerbaijan's CBC radio starts broadcasting in Karabakh
Iran's Khorasan Razavi Province to increase trade with Turkmenistan
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva made Instagram post on Shusha (VIDEO)
Iran to import Coronavirus vaccine - President Rouhani
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan implementing road and railroad construction projects
Competitions in Baku always held at highest level - Slovenian gymnast
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry discloses events to be held on occasion of Victory Day - May 9
Buy/sell operations at Iran Mercantile Exchange revealed
Iran Khodro Diesel Company boots its production
Azerbaijan’s Baku city always warmly welcoming - Ukrainian gymnast
Uzbekistan's international reserves grow
Sri Lanka approves Pfizer COVID vaccine for emergency use
Turkmenistan signs decree on pardon for Qadr Night
Uzbekistan Railways plans to resume railway communication with Russia and Kazakhstan
Iran's IMIDRO begins study of public and comparative discovery in Albalaq mine
Azerbaijan’s Azerenergy company names winner of tenders for maintenance of IT equipment
Number of Azerbaijani insurance companies entitled to operate within Green Card system increase
Kazakhstan’s Intergas Central Asia company opens tender to attract services
Baku Stock Exchange unveils 4M2021 transactions on corporate securities
Azerbaijan expanding cooperation with Czech Republic in nanotechnologies
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for May 8
Uzbekistan suspends flights to Turkey and India
Scientific conferences, organized by Baku Higher Oil School on occasion of 98th anniversary of National Leader Heydar Aliyev, are coming to an end (PHOTO)
Uzbek ministry extends tender for pumping and power equipment
Saudi Crown Prince, Pakistan’s PM hold talks as bilateral agreements, MoUs signed
Russia records another 8,329 new daily coronavirus cases
Kazakh-Turkish JV launches tender to attract equipment inspection services
Iran's Shahid Tondgooyan Petrochemical Company plans to increase production
Azerbaijani Central Bank makes allocations for software platform support
Israel among 12 ‘green’ countries okayed for UK summer travelers
Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku organized at high level - Georgian gymnast
Kazakh oil refinery opens tender to attract examination services
Int'l Judo Federation thanks Azerbaijan for return of previously detained Armenian judoka
Kazakh Gas Processing Plant opens tender on supply of diesel fuel
Interest in Georgian aviation market growing amid COVID-19
Auto sector urges U.S. Congress to help fund its computer chip needs
Iran’s ISOICO declares amount of attracted funds
Mine clearance work on Fuzuli-Ahmadbayli highway continues in Azerbaijan (PHOTO)
Turkmenistan exceeds plan for transport, communication sector
World Cup competitions at Baku National Gymnastics Arena continue (PHOTO)
Georgia reports 1,564 new coronavirus cases for May 8
Data of Turkmenistan’s construction sector revealed
Supplies of Uzbek cherries to foreign markets to decrease
PASHA Capital - 4M2021 leader in Baku Stock Exchange operations
Uzbekistan developing strategy for promoting textile products to EU market
Turkmenistan records growth in agro-industrial production
S. Korean company eyes producing medical devices in Uzbekistan’s Kashkadarya region
Iran’s GTC unveils volume of wheat purchased from farmers
Prices for gold, silver continue to rise in Azerbaijan
Indicators of Turkmenistan’s oil, gas sector growing
Uzbekistan reveals COVID-19 data for May 8
France to impose quarantines for arrivals from 7 more countries, including UAE, Qatar
Turkish Energy Ministry bans local company from participating in BOTAS tenders
Russian, Tajik presidents to discuss bilateral ties, Tajik-Kyrgyz border clashes
EU calls on U.S. and others to export their vaccines
All news