India struggles to tame its heart of darkness

( Reuter )- Young girls and their mothers huddle under shawls in the central reservation of one of the city's main streets, picking through trash for grimy metal scraps that might earn them 20 rupees (half a dollar) a day.

Buses and auto rickshaws belt out black fumes beside them on the congested, muddy street, dogs pick through huge piles of garbage by the roadside, men urinate at their side.

This is Patna, the capital city of Bihar, India's poorest and one of its slowest growing states economically. On a rainy day, Patna can seem like some post-apocalyptic nightmare, with poverty, misery and ugliness around every corner.

So far, India has failed to trickle the benefits of its economic boom down to Bihar, a failure which could have serious political and economic repercussions. People here feel the rest of the country is simply not paying attention.

"Everyone has discarded Bihar, they think of it as a nightmare," said businessman Rajesh Singh.

"They only talk about the good things in India, they don't even look at Bihar. But this is 10 percent of India's population, you can't just chuck it away."

Bihar is home to around 90 million people and has one-seventh of India's poor, but accounts for just 1.6 percent of its gross domestic product. By any measure, literacy, infant mortality, malnourishment, it sits at or near the bottom in South Asia.

The World Bank put the challenge in its most tactful terms when lending Bihar's government $225 million (115 million pounds) last December.

"If large differences in growth rates between rich and poor states persist, these could eventually translate into vast differences in material well-being," it said. "Bihar lies at the heart of India's inclusive growth agenda."

Shaibal Gupta of the Asian Development Research Institute (ADRI) in Patna divides India into the sunrise states, those which are integrating into the global economy, and the sunset states, like Bihar and its larger neighbor Uttar Pradesh, which are rapidly being left behind.

Bihar is metaphorically and sometimes literally India's heart of darkness -- there is so little power in Bihar, night-time satellite images show it as a massive black hole.

Crumbling roads, corrupt or inept governance and a reputation for unbridled lawlessness only add to the gloom.

" India will face problems if Bihar doesn't develop," Gupta said.

Bihar's economy failed to register any growth in the first half of the 1990s, and has grown at just under four percent since, less than half the current national growth rate and barely one percent in per capita terms.

Chief Minister Nitish Kumar took over two years ago promising a new era, and his reforms won some praise from the World Bank.

Criminal convictions were almost unheard of in the reign of Laloo Prasad Yadav and his wife Rabri Devi. A new system of speedy trials helped secure nearly 10,000 convictions in 2007.

Kidnapping for ransom, Bihar's biggest industry in Laloo's days, has fallen four-fold. In the past two years, more than 200 cases have been registered against corrupt government officials.

But private investment remains tiny, and a new era of fiscal responsibility in New Delhi means the kind of public investment required to transform Bihar is almost out of the question.

" Japan and Korea developed as industrial countries with the full support of the state," said the ADRI's Gupta. "In Bihar the state is very weak."

Rural migrants squat on the grass verges outside government ministers' houses in Patna, under plastic sheets, encampments that they say are "too horrible" when it rains.

Thousands of homes were damaged in last year's floods, and villagers tired of waiting for work under a new government rural employment guarantee scheme have left.

Bihar has a long history of migration dating back to the 19th century, when large numbers of people left as indentured labor to overseas British colonies or to find work on plantations in neighboring Assam or in factories in West Bengal.

Today, as much of India booms, laborers from Bihar are migrating all over the country.

In the cities, the influx spells tension, and sometimes violence. Today nearly 11 percent of New Delhi's population hails from Bihar, another 40 percent from Uttar Pradesh.

Biharis are often looked down upon in Delhi, and blamed for rising crime -- the city's chief minister Sheila Dikshit publicly wonders how to turn back the tide.

In Mumbai, tensions between locals and migrants boiled over this month when a small right-wing Hindu-nationalist party stoked the flames with a campaign against "outsiders."

Taxi drivers, most of whom hail from Bihar or Uttar Pradesh were beaten up, a few vehicles damaged, and a bottle thrown over the wall of the house of Amitabh Bachchan, India's biggest film star, himself from Uttar Pradesh.

But the problem of Bihar -- and by extension the problem of India's widening inequality -- has even broader implications.

The Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party was kicked out of office in 2004 in a shock general election result, seen partly as an indictment of its failure to reach the rural poor.

The Congress-led coalition which has succeeded has made little headway with the type of economic reforms its prime minister and finance minister are associated with.

Put simply, the political consensus for further economic reforms which India may need to sustain its boom, will simply not be there if those reforms do not benefit the poor.

Some companies are already suffering shortages of skilled labor that are pushing up wage costs. If India leaves millions of rural poor unskilled and illiterate, its economic upturn could find itself built on a shaky foundation, economists warn.

"If you think Bihar is not your problem, it will be your problem very soon," said businessman Singh.

Weekly actual topics in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Weekly actual topics in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Weekly tenders in the region (April 16-20)
Weekly tenders in the region (April 16-20)
Last week’s laws, orders and decrees in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Last week’s laws, orders and decrees in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Loading Bars
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for February 25
AzTV will investigate historical assasinations (PHOTO)
Kazakhstan eyes to host meeting of Turkic Council countries' energy ministers in 2022
Zarif urges South Korea to release Iran's blocked assets
UK eager to restart U.S. talks on tariff removal
Saipem expects capex to rise in 2021
Central Bank of Azerbaijan announces winner of tender for survey on household plans
Central Bank of Azerbaijan shares data on revenues of Azerbaijani insurance companies
Number of trucks crossing through Iran's Jolfa border checkpoint revealed
German companies eye 'green economy' dev't projects in Kazakhstan
Kazakh investors interested in several sectors of Turkish economy
Assets of pawnshops and microcredit organizations in Uzbekistan increase
Kazakhstan's major copper company reveals its 2021 production guidance
Turkey's activity on Turkmenistan’s exchange in Jan.2021
Azerbaijani president takes part in ceremony of providing families of martyrs, disabled with apartments (PHOTO)
Details of import-export via Iran's Bushehr Province announced
President Ilham Aliyev attends opening of Shaghan Rehabilitation Pension (PHOTO)
KAZ Minerals provides update on Baimskaya Project in co-op with Russia
Military coup attempt in Armenia - PM inviting supporters to Republic Square
Uzbek agriculture ministry to create system to monitor irrigated lands
Pashinyan dismisses head of General Staff
Armenian General Staff demands Pashinyan's resignation
Azerbaijani banks' foreign currency demand down
Azerbaijan privatizes several district public properties via auctions
Turkmenistan prepares to host transport conference for landlocked developing countries
Bakcell launches internet package for online education and work
Iran starts exporting products from Tombak port
Georgian PM appoints Vice PMs
Extraction from Iran's South Pars gas field exceeds plan
Kazakhstan's KAZ Minerals reports increase in revenues
TOP-5 trading partners of Azerbaijan in Jan. 2021
Georgia to extend grace period for auto importers
Saipem’s capex down, net financial debt up in 2020
Kazakh national atomic company's subsidiary opens tender to repair vehicles
Saipem sees decrease in revenues due to slowdown of projects
Barclays lifts 2021 oil price outlook on tighter U.S. supply view
Azerbaijani MFA comments on statements by Luxembourg's FM
Khojaly genocide - heaviest crime of last century, says Turkish Parliament's chairman
Turkey records more revenue from Jan.2021 car exports to France
Uzbekistan eyes purchasing helicopters from Airbus
Turkey always next to Azerbaijan - speaker of Turkish Parliament
Volumes of agricultural products export in Turkmenistan’s Lebap region revealed
Annual profit margin of Georgian banks increases
Azerbaijan's export of plastics over Jan. 2021 shows substantial growth
Iranian parliament shares grief of relatives of victims of Khojaly tragedy
Upgrading of Internet equipment in Azerbaijan's Khachmaz district continues - Ministry
Uzbekistan to fund introduction of drip irrigation technology for cotton growing
Europe’s gas trade to decline to 450 bcm by 2050
Kazakh gas producing company opens tender to buy spares for wells repair
Turkmenistan to send cargo flight to Turkey
Kazakhstan boosts mutual trade with Germany amid COVID-19
Ukrainian companies eye creating logistics center in Turkmenistan’s seaport
Chip shortage leads Japan automakers to post 4.5% slump in January global output
Georgia sees decrease in COVID-19 cases
Direct impacts of COVID-19 on gas market to be evident through to 2030
Baku Higher Oil School, Stockholm University to start training cybersecurity specialists
Aston Martin expects better 2021 sales after deep losses
Kazakhstan's expenses for importing Turkey-made steel grow in Jan.2021
IGB can be extended to eastern, northeastern Europe
Iranian president inaugurates Abyek-Varamin Highway
Azerbaijan shares footage from Gubadly district's Yusifbayli village (VIDEO)
Indian citizen Kaushik Barua conferred with Royal Order in Cambodia
India set to manufacture containers to boost exports
GUAM commemorates Azerbaijan's Khojaly Genocide
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan preparing for demarcation of state borders
World's largest cricket stadium renamed as Narendra Modi Stadium
Ukraine receives first Covid-19 vaccine doses
UAE establishes executive office to combat money laundering, terror financing
Reconstruction Work Of 66th School Under Indian Aid Begins In Nepal's Dakshinkali
Senior Officials Of India, France, Australia Discuss Further Cooperation In Indo-Pacific
Gold price in Azerbaijan decreases
Uzbekistan reveals COVID-19 data for Feb. 25
ERIELL int’l oilfield services group working on increasing hydrocarbon production in Uzbekistan
Georgian Crystal's refinancing plan carries elevated execution risk
Turkey issues data on ships received at Kocaeli port during Jan. 2021
Azerbaijani oil prices continue to grow
Azerbaijani currency rates for Feb. 25
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on February 27
Pakistan announces opening of flights to Azerbaijan
Iran's Minister of Tourism explains health protocols in coming Nowruz trips
N. Macedonia’s ICT sector may be attractive for Azerbaijani investors – minister
Another Italian municipality officially condemns Khojaly genocide against Azerbaijani civilians
Iran's Rouhani asks US to pave way for talks
Iran cooperates with Germany, Afghanistan to develop renewable energy sector
Iranian gov't, Expediency Council hold another meeting on FATF bills
N. Macedonia names energy, tourism most productive sectors for co-op with Azerbaijan
N.Macedonia, Azerbaijan negotiating on trade agreement
Oil prices hit 13-month highs on tighter supplies, Fed assurance on low rates
Iran and US negotiate only within JCPOA framework
Australian media reforms pass parliament after last-ditch changes
Decrease in bank lending observed in Baku and Azerbaijani districts
Appeals to consulting organizations in Azerbaijan growing dynamically - Azecoconsulting
Azerbaijan Industrial Corporation aiming to restructure portfolio
China becomes Uzbekistan’s main foreign trade partner
Azerbaijan's Central Bank publishes latest data on population's bank deposits
Azerbaijan discloses share of household loans in total lending
Azerbaijani State Migration Service opens tender to buy air transport services
Kazakhstan to reduce VAT for new manufacturing companies
New Turkish ambassadors to Washington, Tokyo officially appointed
Municipal transport to operate on weekends in Georgia
All news