Bush Orders Satellite to be Shot Down

(The Washington Post) - A Navy cruiser in the Pacific Ocean will try an unprecedented shoot down of an out-of-control, school bus-sized spy satellite loaded with a toxic fuel as it begins its plunge to Earth, national security officials said Thursday.

President Bush made the decision because it was impossible to predict where a tank containing the fuel might land in an uncontrolled descent.

The Pentagon decided to use a modified, ship-fired anti-ballistic missile to make the attempt sometime after Feb. 20 to avoid creating debris that could threaten the space shuttle on its return from the International Space Station, according to a military source.

Gen. James Cartwright, the vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said the Navy missile will be fired as the satellite re-enters the atmosphere and "has a reasonably high opportunity for success." The Pentagon and NASA have been working on the missile modifications for the last three weeks.

Deputy National Security Adviser James Jeffrey said the decision was based on the fact that the satellite is carrying a substantial amount of a hazardous rocket fuel, hydrazine.

When the pending crash was first announced last month, however, National Security Council spokesman Gordon Johndroe minimized the danger, saying that the potential for pieces hitting any populated area was "very small."

Unless it is shot down, the satellite, which has been out of ground communication since its launch more than a year ago, is expected "to make an uncontrolled reentry ... on or about March 6," according to documents the Bush administration provided to the United Nations Thursday. "At present," said an official notification sent Thursday to countries around the world as well as the U.N. and NATO, "we cannot predict the entry impact area."

Officials Thursday acknowledged that many satellites - some of them much larger - have fallen to earth in the past without harm. But they said the presence of 1,000 pounds of hydrazine - unexpended fuel contained in a 40-inch sphere that was likely to hit the ground intact - led Bush to approve the Pentagon's recommendation to attempt the shootdown.

The announcement set off an immediate debate on defense blogs and among experts who questioned whether there was an ulterior motive. Some experts said the military was seizing an opportunity to test its controversial missile defense system against a satellite target.

But others noted that the Standard missile 3 has successfully been tested against warhead targets, which are far smaller than the satellite.

"There has to be another reason behind this," said Michael Krepon, co-founder of the Henry L. Stimson Center, a liberal arms-control advocacy organization. "In the history of the space age, there has not been a single human being who has been harmed by man-made objects falling from space."

NASA administrator Michael Griffin insisted that the interception was not a ruse to try the defense system on a satellite or to one-up other countries that have made similar attempts. The administration was harshly critical of China when it destroyed an aging satellite in orbit.

The difference, Griffin said, "is, one, we are notifying, which is required by treaties and law. OK?" The Chinese satellite was destroyed at a much higher altitude - about 600 miles - creating a field of orbiting space debris that creates hazards for other spacecraft.

The United States and Soviet Union conducted anti-satellite tests in the mid-1980s but stopped once it became clear that the debris from the destroyed spacecraft became a danger to other satellites and even spaceships. Griffin said the low altitude at which the satellite will be targeted - about 150 miles - would minimize orbiting debris.

"The lower we can catch this, the quicker the debris reenters," he said. More than half the pieces will burn up or hit Earth before making two revolutions around the Earth and the rest will come down in "weeks, maybe a month, but it's a very finite period of time that we can manage."

Jeffrey said that the fuel tank was the only piece of the craft that was not expected to explode on reentry and it was hoped the missile could destroy it in space. If it hits the earth, it could leak gas and cause potentially fatal injury over an area of the size of about two football fields, he said, adding that "this is all about trying to reduce the danger to human beings."

Other experts, however, said they believed the heat of reentry would cause the tank to explode safely high in the air.

Two additional U.S. Navy cruisers, with backup missiles, have been configured for a second and third chance, if necessary, he said, although the window for shooting down the spacecraft is quite small.

The National Reconnaissance Organization satellite lost contact with ground control soon after it was launched in December 2006. Never ordered to burn its maneuvering fuel, it still carries about 1,000 pounds of frozen hydrazine, a substance Cartwright compared to "similar to chlorine or to ammonia in that when you inhale it, it affects your tissues in your lungs ... It has the burning sensation. If you stay very close to it an inhale a lot of it, it could in fact be deadly."

The Columbia spacecraft, which lost control and hit the earth in 2003, also contained a canister of hydrazine gas that landed intact in a Texas woodland. The Columbia was at the end of its mission, however, and most of the hydrazine had already burned up.

Cartwright said that the Aegis missile system aboard the cruiser would fire an SM-3 Standard missile with a heat-seeking nose that destroys its target by hitting it, not blowing it up. The missile, known as Block III, was developed primarily for a tactical intermediate missile defense against warheads coming in at low altitude. The Navy has spent the past three weeks modifying missile software normally set for hitting much higher targets, he said.

Asked whether this was really an attempt to test the Aegis system for use as an anti-satellite system - which would be a very controversial step internationally - Cartwright said the amount of special modifications being done to the programs used to guide the system would "not be transferable to fleet use."

He also rejected widely disseminated blog allegations that the destruction of the satellite had been planned to keep classified information aboard from landing in non-U.S. hands. Everything other than the gas container, he said, would be blown to pieces on reentry even without the missile hit, he said.

Members of Congress were briefed on the plan Thursday, as were diplomats from other nations. House Armed Services Committee Chairman Ike Skelton said in a statement that "I attended a Congressional briefing this morning by the Department of Defense, and I am satisfied that the destruction of the malfunctioning satellite is the best option available to protect public safety."

"However, it should be understood by all, at home and abroad, that this is an exceptional circumstance and should not be perceived as the standard U.S. policy for dealing with errant satellites," he said. "The House Armed Services Committee will work closely with the Department of Defense and other concerned agencies to oversee the broader policy implications of this action in relation to our space assets."

Iran issues data on necessary commodities released from its customs
Iran issues data on necessary commodities released from its customs
Azerbaijani currency rates for March 3
Azerbaijani currency rates for March 3
Iran's CBI discloses number and value of exchanged checks
Iran's CBI discloses number and value of exchanged checks
Loading Bars
Latest
COVAX initiative becoming irrelevant: injustice and inequality
Revenues from state insurance payments in Azerbaijan increases - minister
Kazakhstan’s Air Astana company resuming flights to Georgia
Slovenian Railways wants to boost co-op with Azerbaijan in passenger transportation
Turkmenistan interested in developing projects with IOM, using digital technologies
Brent prices to reach $80/bbl by 2Q22 even with OPEC+’s output back to 2019 level
Saudi Arabia to end its voluntary oil production cut
Israel eyes scaling up co-op with Uzbekistan to save Aral Sea
Кazakh Electricity Grid Operating Company opens tender to buy construction materials
Azerbaijan reveals latest data on sales through Azexport portal
Uzbek-Korean JV to buy spare parts for emergency diesel generator via tender
Brent price still vulnerable to any disappointments around global vaccinations
Iran issues data on necessary commodities released from its customs
Pakistani military delegation in Azerbaijan on official visit
Turkey's revenues from exporting cars to Israel down
Turkey reveals number of ships received at Gemlik port in Jan. 2021
Turkey's exports to OIC countries on the rise
Azerbaijani currency rates for March 3
Accreditation of national media for F1 Azerbaijan Grand Prix 2021 begins
Iran's Fereydonkenar Port joins Caspian Sea transportation network
Number of coronavirus cases in Uzbekistan passes 80,000
Oil rises on demand hopes after days of sell-off
Bulgarian companies could participate in recovery projects in Azerbaijan's liberated lands - Ambassador (INTERVIEW)
Finance minister Sunak to promise 'whatever it takes' in new COVID budget plan
Turkish auto sales grow 24.2% in February
Kyrgyzstan introduces temporary ban on export of oil products
EIB, European Council presidents open new EU premises in Georgia
Iran ready to export medical technologies to Syria
Hungary interested in including Azerbaijani gas in country's future energy mix - ambassador (INTERVIEW)
ExxonMobil to cut 7% of its workforce in Singapore
2021 Emmy Awards to be held in September
Ireland to re-establish diplomatic presence in Iran
Azerbaijan to contribute to development of CE work on organizing AI security
Biden takes steps to help Merck boost Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine supply
US Department of Commerce blacklists 14 entities in Russia, Germany, Switzerland
Chinese embassy opposes Indian media's allegation on cyberattacks
OPEC sees positive oil market outlook, continued downside risks
Iran's CBI discloses number and value of exchanged checks
Italian Parliament demands provision of maps of mined areas of Azerbaijan (PHOTO)
AZAL Announces Conditions for Rebooking Tickets for Flights Canceled due to COVID-19 Pandemic
Singapore's manufacturing PMI falls to 50.5 in February
Promise to provide countries with necessary vaccines within COVAX initiative is not fulfilled - State Agency of Medical Insurance
Parliament head to support all joint efforts for new constitution
Georgian President appreciates EU support
Macron to hold phone talk with Iranian counterpart over JCPOA
OECD recommends Georgia to support land registration reform for increasing FDI-SME linkages
Turkmenistan reveals schedule of intercity buses
Azerbaijan's State Tax Service registers Fuzuli Airport LLC
Azerbaijan felt Turkey's support not only during Karabakh war but throughout history - Minister
Int’l Model Non-Aligned Movement Simulation Exercise underway - Azerbaijan Foreign Ministry
Azerbaijan, Germany interested in increasing mutual trade turnover - Deputy minister
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on March 3
Azerbaijani State Agency of Automobile Roads talks about repair and construction on roads
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry places medium-term bonds at auction
Azerbaijan shows footage from Ucbulag village of Fuzuli district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Georgia to receive first doses of COVID-19 vaccine via Covax platform in February
Irrigation systems to be put into operation in Iran’s agricultural sector
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry shares updated list of martyred servicemen in Second Karabakh War
Larization of loans increase in Georgia
Georgian AgroZone products to be exported abroad from Kutaisi Airport
Turkish specialists together with Azerbaijan’s AzTV to shoot film in Nagorno-Karabakh region
Ro-Pax ferry vessel commissioned by Azerbaijan's president - video report
Azerbaijani winemakers’ production down in 2020
Azerbaijan, Tajikistan discuss development of tourism co-op
Georgia’s banking sector begins year with profit
France uses only quarter of Astrazeneca vaccine doses
Uzbek-Korean JV to buy spare parts for electric actuator via tender
Kazakhstan identifies priority tasks to develop agriculture by 2025
Georgian Ministry of Finance sees decrease in mobilized income tax
Likelihood of interest rate decrease in Azerbaijan for 2021 seems minimal - Unicapital
Azerbaijan's AzNET segment neutralizes more phishing attacks in Jan.2021
Azerbaijan's new borrowings not to raise debt burden - Gazprombank
Azerbaijan studying Turkey's experience to strengthen institution of primary health care (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan talk big potential for co-op in agriculture
Hertz set to ride out of bankruptcy with $4.2 billion from investment firms
Money transfers via int'l payment systems down in Kazakhstan
Azercell obtains yet another award on customer experience management
German companies may take part in restoring Azerbaijan's liberated lands - ambassador
Excavation of well in Iran's Ahvaz oil field launched
Uzbekistan considers resuming air communication with Russia
Bahar Azadi gold coin price again falling in Iran
Kazakhstan, Georgia resume mutual flights as COVID-19 restrictions lifted
Uzbekistan eyes expanding mutually beneficial relations with foreign partners
Azerbaijan and Germany to continue co-op on improving qualifications of managers
Generation data of Iran's Shahid Rajaee TPP announced
Lithuania supports subsidizing renewable energy projects in Georgia
Demand for pick-up trucks in Azerbaijan may increase - expert
Kazakhstan boosts agriculture output, sets up tasks for sector's dev't
Turkey issues Jan. 2021 data on passenger traffic at Istanbul Airport
Azerbaijani company discloses output of primary aluminum
Spain's jobless hit four million for first time in five years as pandemic curbs bite
Volume of exports from Iran's Qom Province increases
S.Korean oil company holding exploration on land plots in Uzbekistan
EU executive says joint vaccine strategy not unravelling
Azerbaijan, Germany discuss expanding cooperation in oil & gas sector
Azerbaijani business environment entering recovery period - Minister of Economy
Iran's awaits action from US over JCPOA
Indonesia says identifies two cases of British COVID-19 variant
Europe – Iran held business forum to expand trade
Uzbek-Russian JV completes geological exploration at Akchalak investment block
All news