"Shocking revelations" on Jerusalem

"Shocking revelations" on Jerusalem

One of the most shocking revelations of The Palestine Papers obtained by Al Jazeera relates to the demographic and territorial concessions that the Palestinian Authority was willing to give on Jerusalem.

The papers show that not only did PA negotiators demonstrate a willingness to accept Israel's annexation of all the settlements in Jerusalem, except Jabal Abu Ghneim (Har Homa), but that they were also willing to disown parts of the besieged Arab neighbourhoods in the city. Worse still, Saeb Erekat, the chief negotiator, displayed clear "flexibility" regarding the sovereignty on the Haram al-Sharif.

As Ahmed Qurei described the PA's concessions on East Jerusalem settlements, this was "the first time in history that we make such a proposition; we refused to do so in Camp David."

For their part, the Israelis, during negotiations in 2008, refused to return to the point at which the Camp David talks collapsed in July 2000. Udi Dekel, the head of the Israeli team, pointed this out in a May 29, 2008 meeting with Samih al-Abid, the PA's map expert:

"Since 2000, something happened in those 8 years. So we are not at the same starting point. You started a terror war on us and we created facts on the ground. This is the reality that we live in today, so we can't go back to Camp David. Circumstances changed considerably since then."

"I will not betray my people"
The first time the two sides ever discussed the status of occupied East Jerusalem - and, in particular, its holy sites - was at Camp David in 2000. Under international law, Jerusalem (including the Haram al-Sharif/Temple Mount) is regarded as part of the illegally occupied Palestinian territories. Notwithstanding, Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak and Palestinian president Yasser Arafat attempted to negotiate the issue during their Camp David summit. Several participants in the controversial talks confirm that their failure to resolve the status of the Old City's holy sites contributed to its acrimonious collapse.

At Camp David, the Clinton administration's proposal was premised on a general principle that "Arab areas are Palestinian and Jewish areas are Israeli." However, the proposals on the Haram were exceedingly problematic: They seemed to recognize Israel's sovereignty under the Haram. Other aspects of the proposal seemed to prepare the conditions for Palestinian enclaves within the city, all separated from each other. But the Israelis, unlike the Palestinians, seemed set to maintain contiguity.

Hence, while in theory the Clinton proposal called for "maximum contiguity for both," in practice it translated into "maximum contiguity for Israel."

Realizing the dire consequences of such an outcome, Arafat rejected the offer and defended the Palestine Liberation Organization's unwillingness to compromise on the sovereignty of the Haram. His was a principled position that quickly earned him the scorn of Israelis and Americans alike - though universal support at home, and throughout the Islamic world.

In what was by all accounts a bruising encounter, Arafat told Clinton, "The Palestinian leader who will give up Jerusalem has not yet been born. I will not betray my people or the trust they have placed in me. Do not look to me to legitimize the occupation! Of course, it can continue longer, but it cannot last forever."

Newfound "flexibility"
The Palestine Papers show that ten years later the leadership of PLO, now substantially weakened and fragmented, was prepared to deviate from the red line laid down by Arafat. At least one member of its executive committee, Saeb Erekat, has demonstrated this willingness to show "flexibility" on the Haram.

Whether he made the following overtures to win the admiration of his American counterparts, or merely to break the deadlock created by the extremist Netanyahu government, it is not clear; what is absolutely clear, though, is that the proposed tinkering with the legal status of the Haram al-Sharif is dangerous and unprecedented. Despite the obvious the risks entailed, Erekat nonetheless, made this "creative" suggestion on October 21st 2009 during a meeting in Washington. He told Obama adviser David Hale and State Department legal adviser Jonathan Schwartz:

"Even the Old City can be worked out except for the Haram and what they call Temple Mount. There you need the creativity of people like me..."

When Schwartz asked whether they were to discuss Jerusalem with the borders or separately, Erekat replied:

"It's solved. You have the Clinton Parameters formula. For the Old City sovereignty for Palestine, except the Jewish quarter and part of the Armenian quarter...the Haram can be left to be discussed - there are creative ways, having a body or a committee, having undertakings for example not to dig."

It is evident from this exchange that; whereas Arafat had rejected the Clinton parameters, the current Palestinian team (led by Erekat) is prepared to accept it.

Furthermore, he conceded that the Jewish Quarter and part of the Armenian Quarter would be under Israeli sovereignty. By so doing, Erekat was, in effect, moving the current Armistice ["Green"] Line, which is currently far away from the Haram al-Sharif and outside the Old City, to rest exactly at the Haram's walls. (It must be recalled that when the Jewish Quarter was confiscated by the Israelis on 18 April 1968, only 105 of the 595 houses were owned by Jews.)

More alarmingly, Erekat's suggestion of "a body or a committee" to solve the issue of the Haram demonstrated his unreserved flexibility over the sovereignty of the Haram itself. It indicates it is not a red line any more.

To highlight the extent of the PA's offer on Jerusalem, Erekat on January 15, 2010 told George Mitchell's staff: "What is in that paper gives them the biggest Yerushalaim in Jewish history..."

From the beginning, Erekat was well aware of the acute sensitivity of the issue of the Haram to Arabs and Muslims. He confirmed this to US assistant secretary of state David Welch after the Annapolis meeting on 2 December 2008, when he said that, to the Saudis, "Jerusalem is the Haram."

It is notable in The Palestine Papers that even Condoleezza Rice realised the extreme sensitivity of the Haram, telling the Palestinian and Israeli negotiators in a July 29, 2008 meeting that on the Haram "your children's children will not have an agreement." She called on both sides to" leave it unresolved."

But the chief Palestinian negotiator appeared totally disconnected from his own people, as well as his wider Arab and Muslim constituency, when he made this "creative" overture about Old City and the Haram. He apparently, was so consumed by the negotiations that he became oblivious of the import of his remarks among Arabs, Muslims and - most of all - his own people. Even among some Israelis this seemed infantile; as Israeli lawyer Daniel Seidemann observed in a recent article, "any attempt to construe the API (Arab Palestine Initiative) in a manner that falls short of "full-stop" Palestinian or Arab sovereignty on the Haram/Mount would be an exercise in self-delusion."


Industrial enterprises to be put into operation in Iran’s Tehran Province
Industrial enterprises to be put into operation in Iran’s Tehran Province
Azerbaijani Economy Ministry announces winner of tender on assessment of feasibility study
Azerbaijani Economy Ministry announces winner of tender on assessment of feasibility study
Iran providing much needed mechanization for farmers in Qazvin Province
Iran providing much needed mechanization for farmers in Qazvin Province
Loading Bars
Latest
Azerbaijan Army holds several events on occasion of 76th anniversary of Victory (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan increases export of textile products
Georgian President to visit North Macedonia on May 10
MasterCard intends to work with Turkmenistan to improve level of electronic payments
Gazelli Group congratulates Second World War veterans in its own unique way (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 9
Azerbaijan reports 660 new COVID-19 cases, 1,539 recoveries
Azerbaijani ombudsman appeals to international organizations
Bulgarian team takes first place at World Cup in Baku in group exercises with three hoops and two pairs of clubs
Discussions underway to resume Tabriz-Baku flights - Iranian official
Awarding ceremony held within Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku (PHOTO)
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for May 9
Turkey discloses volume of cargo transshipped through Aliaga port
Bulgarian gymnast grabs gold in exercise with ribbon at Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku
76th anniversary of Victory in Great Patriotic War celebrated in Shusha (PHOTO)
Israeli gymnast grabs gold in exercise with clubs at Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku
Leadership of Azerbaijani MoD paid tribute to memory of compatriots, who died in Great Patriotic War (PHOTO)
Baku holds award ceremony of winners and prize-winners of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup at National Gymnastics Arena (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani team grabs bronze in exercise with 5 balls at Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku
Italian gymnast grabs gold in exercise with ball at Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku
Israeli gymnast grabs gold in exercise with hoop at Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku
Final day of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup starts in Baku - Azerbaijani graces competing for medals (PHOTO)
Industrial enterprises to be put into operation in Iran’s Tehran Province
Azerbaijani Economy Ministry announces winner of tender on assessment of feasibility study
Turkey discloses number of ships received by Bandirma port from Jan. through March 2021
Azerbaijani president, first lady pay tribute to Azerbaijanis who made unparalleled contribution to victory over fascism (PHOTO/VİDEO)
EU and India agree to resume trade talks at virtual summit
Azerbaijan strongly condemns attempts to distort truth about WW2, justify fascism - MFA
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva makes Instagram post on Victory Day over fascism (PHOTO)
India's COVID-19 tally surpasses 22 mln with over 400,000 new cases
China’s Long March-5B carrier rocket’s last stage enters atmosphere
Brazil sees 2,202 more COVID-19 deaths
Red Cross to hand over Georgia 100 thousand Sinopharm vaccine shots
Russia's 2M2021 import of Turkish cars grows in value
Turkey reports 18,052 new COVID-19 cases, 5,016,141 in total
“Covo-Pasteur”, “Barakat” vaccine to hit market soon: Rouhani
Daily COVID-19 case count at 2,350 in Kazakhstan
China reports 12 new COVID-19 cases vs seven a day earlier
Chile reports third consecutive day of over 6,000 daily COVID-19 cases
UN remembers the dead of WWII
2 people, including child, shot in NYC Times Square
Attack on Syrian government forces repelled in Idlib, at least ten militants killed
WHO records over 817,000 new daily cases of COVID-19 worldwide
Iraq decides to quarantine evacuees from India for 14 days as total cases hit 1,108,558
UK records another 2,047 coronavirus cases, 5 deaths
Azerbaijan marks Day of Victory in Great Patriotic War
Iranian trucks do not transport goods to Karabakh - Iranian embassy
NCDC: Georgia to receive extra half a million Sinopharm vaccine doses in June
Iran may extend cooperation on inspections with IAEA
Consumers must protect IoT devices - Fortinet
Azerbaijan’s Baku city has beautiful National Gymnastics Arena – Russian gymnast
Baku holds awarding ceremony of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani team reaches finals in group exercises as part of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup (PHOTO)
WB plans to issue loan to finance another road project in Azerbaijan
Any attempt to glorify fascism is disgusting - Russian expert
Group team competitions underway in Baku as part of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani ADA University sсreens film timed to Day of Victory in WWII (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan names finalists in exercise with clubs as part of gymnastics World Cup in Baku
Azerbaijani gymnast reaches finals in exercise with ribbon as part of World Cup in Baku
Iran providing much needed mechanization for farmers in Qazvin Province
Germany’s import of steel from Turkey up
Azerbaijani president allocates funds for construction of new school in Shusha
Funds allocated for construction, repairs of educational institutions in Baku
Uzbekistan interested in co-op with French pharmaceutical company
Funds allocated for creation of heat supply system in Azerbaijan’s Shusha
France’s import of steel from Turkey up
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on May 9
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry places medium-term bonds on auction
Cotton spinning factory of Turkmenistan’s Lebap region names production data
Chevron should remain cautious in further increasing oil & gas production
Azerbaijan to continue online lessons in 10th-11th grades, minister says
Foreign shipping lines expected to return to Iran
Austria increases import of steel from Turkey
Fars Province to be connected to north-east and south-east of Iran via railway line
1Q2021 value of operations via interbank national settlements system in Azerbaijan down
United Arab Bank turns around with Dh10.2 million net profit
Azerbaijan's MoD shares video about Shusha - cultural capital of Azerbaijan
New jobs created in Iran's Ardabil Province
Turkmenistan's Turkmengas opens tender for overhaul of gas turbine engines
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price falls
World Cup in Baku became one of my favorite competitions - Azerbaijani gymnast (PHOTO)
Khazar Consortium opens tender for purchase of controller
Value of Iran's import of Turkish steel in 4M2021 grows
Russia’s coronavirus reproduction rate remains below 1
Azerbaijan sets up new military units in liberated lands (PHOTO)
Kazakhstan increases exports to UAE
Best moments of second day of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku (PHOTO)
Kazakh gymnast shares impressions of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup taking place in Baku
Cult of personality of Garegin Nzhdeh in Armenia can be compared with that of Hitler in Nazi Germany – Russian analyst
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 8
EU sceptical on vaccine waiver, but ready to discuss proposal
Azerbaijan confirms 649 more COVID-19 cases, 1,720 recoveries
Iran declares details of exports from Ardabil Province
Uzbekistan projects volume of direct foreign investments for 2021
Exports via Iran's Sistan and Baluchestan Province up
Turkey's 4M2021 export of steel to Georgia surges in value
China boosts import of Azerbaijani products y-o-y
Azerbaijan's Central Bank unveils data on foreign exchange transactions over March 2021
Azerbaijani Ro-Pax type ferry reaches Kazakh port of Kuryk (PHOTO)
G-7 countries back Taiwan's observer status in World Health Assembly
All news