France: Immigration Reforms Inadequate

Parliament Should Strengthen Safeguards in Expulsion Cases.

( HRW ) - The French parliament should improve the safeguards in the new immigration bill for those at risk of return to persecution and torture, Human Rights Watch urged in a letter to deputies and senators released today.

"The government is right to act quickly to fix the problem, but its proposal will only help a fraction of those at risk," said Holly Cartner, Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch. "It's now up to parliament to fully implement the European Court's ruling by making in-country appeals the rule rather than the exception."

Parliament is set to debate on September 18 a government bill to reform the nation's immigration and asylum code. Among the proposals is a plan to allow certain failed asylum seekers to remain in France until a judge rules on an appeal. However, many others whom national authorities seek to swiftly eject will remain at risk of mistreatment upon return before their appeal can be heard.

The reform, which would apply only to asylum seekers detained at borders, is in response to a ruling by the European Court of Human Rights in April that the lack of an automatic in-country appeal for asylum seekers in France violates human rights law.

Because of its narrow scope, the reform would fail to protect many of those who fear torture, ill-treatment, or persecution under the Refugee Convention if returned to their countries of origin. Failed asylum seekers whose applications were considered manifestly unfounded or who come from countries deemed to be safe and those who are considered threats to national security could still be expelled while their appeals to the Refugee Appeals Board are pending. Terrorism suspects who appeal Interior Ministry expulsion orders would also continue to have no have access to an automatic in-country appeal.

The European Court ruling is not the first time that France has drawn international criticism for its unsatisfactory approach to protecting against return to abuse. In 2005 and again in 2007, the UN Committee Against Torture determined that France had violated the torture convention because of its lack of effective safeguards in expulsion cases involving risk of return to torture and ill-treatment. In both cases, France ignored requests from the committee to delay expulsion until the committee had reviewed them. The most recent case involved a French-Tunisian man, Adel Tebourski, who was stripped of his French citizenship and deported in August 2006 after serving time in prison for a terrorism-related conviction. Two months after he was deported, the Refugee Appeals Board ruled that he had had a well-founded fear of persecution and should not have been sent to Tunisia.

"Both the UN and the European Court have sent a clear message that France's safeguards aren't up to scratch," said Cartner. "The best way to protect people against unsafe returns is to let them stay in France until their claims have been fully examined."

In June 2007, Human Rights Watch published a report on France, "In the Name of Prevention: Insufficient Safeguards in National Security Removals." Human Rights Watch concluded that France's administrative procedures for expelling and deporting terrorism suspects lack adequate safeguards to protect against rights violations on return. One of its key recommendations was the creation of a right to an automatic in-country appeal.

Azerbaijan's State Tax Service registers Fuzuli Airport LLC
Azerbaijan's State Tax Service registers Fuzuli Airport LLC
Azerbaijan, Germany interested in increasing mutual trade turnover - Deputy minister
Azerbaijan, Germany interested in increasing mutual trade turnover - Deputy minister
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry places medium-term bonds at auction
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry places medium-term bonds at auction
Loading Bars
Latest
AZAL Announces Conditions for Rebooking Tickets for Flights Canceled due to COVID-19 Pandemic
Singapore's manufacturing PMI falls to 50.5 in February
Promise to provide countries with necessary vaccines within COVAX initiative is not fulfilled - State Agency of Medical Insurance
Parliament head to support all joint efforts for new constitution
Georgian President appreciates EU support
Macron to hold phone talk with Iranian counterpart over JCPOA
OECD recommends Georgia to support land registration reform for increasing FDI-SME linkages
Turkmenistan reveals schedule of intercity buses
Azerbaijan's State Tax Service registers Fuzuli Airport LLC
Azerbaijan felt Turkey's support not only during Karabakh war but throughout history - Minister
Int’l Model Non-Aligned Movement Simulation Exercise underway - Azerbaijan Foreign Ministry
Azerbaijan, Germany interested in increasing mutual trade turnover - Deputy minister
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on March 3
Azerbaijani State Agency of Automobile Roads talks about repair and construction on roads
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry places medium-term bonds at auction
Azerbaijan shows footage from Ucbulag village of Fuzuli district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Georgia to receive first doses of COVID-19 vaccine via Covax platform in February
Irrigation systems to be put into operation in Iran’s agricultural sector
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry shares updated list of martyred servicemen in Second Karabakh War
Larization of loans increase in Georgia
Georgian AgroZone products to be exported abroad from Kutaisi Airport
Turkish specialists together with Azerbaijan’s AzTV to shoot film in Nagorno-Karabakh region
Ro-Pax ferry vessel commissioned by Azerbaijan's president - video report
Azerbaijani winemakers’ production down in 2020
Azerbaijan, Tajikistan discuss development of tourism co-op
Georgia’s banking sector begins year with profit
France uses only quarter of Astrazeneca vaccine doses
Uzbek-Korean JV to buy spare parts for electric actuator via tender
Kazakhstan identifies priority tasks to develop agriculture by 2025
Georgian Ministry of Finance sees decrease in mobilized income tax
Likelihood of interest rate decrease in Azerbaijan for 2021 seems minimal - Unicapital
Azerbaijan's AzNET segment neutralizes more phishing attacks in Jan.2021
Azerbaijan's new borrowings not to raise debt burden - Gazprombank
Azerbaijan studying Turkey's experience to strengthen institution of primary health care (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan talk big potential for co-op in agriculture
Hertz set to ride out of bankruptcy with $4.2 billion from investment firms
Money transfers via int'l payment systems down in Kazakhstan
Azercell obtains yet another award on customer experience management
German companies may take part in restoring Azerbaijan's liberated lands - ambassador
Excavation of well in Iran's Ahvaz oil field launched
Uzbekistan considers resuming air communication with Russia
Bahar Azadi gold coin price again falling in Iran
Kazakhstan, Georgia resume mutual flights as COVID-19 restrictions lifted
Uzbekistan eyes expanding mutually beneficial relations with foreign partners
Azerbaijan and Germany to continue co-op on improving qualifications of managers
Generation data of Iran's Shahid Rajaee TPP announced
Lithuania supports subsidizing renewable energy projects in Georgia
Demand for pick-up trucks in Azerbaijan may increase - expert
Kazakhstan boosts agriculture output, sets up tasks for sector's dev't
Turkey issues Jan. 2021 data on passenger traffic at Istanbul Airport
Azerbaijani company discloses output of primary aluminum
Spain's jobless hit four million for first time in five years as pandemic curbs bite
Volume of exports from Iran's Qom Province increases
S.Korean oil company holding exploration on land plots in Uzbekistan
EU executive says joint vaccine strategy not unravelling
Azerbaijan, Germany discuss expanding cooperation in oil & gas sector
Azerbaijani business environment entering recovery period - Minister of Economy
Iran's awaits action from US over JCPOA
Indonesia says identifies two cases of British COVID-19 variant
Europe – Iran held business forum to expand trade
Uzbek-Russian JV completes geological exploration at Akchalak investment block
Azerbaijani electricity supplier first to use special-purpose UAVs
Iran reaches gas export growth
Turkish president instructs to shoot TV series about Karabakh war victory
Cargo, passenger traffic via Turkish Sabiha Gokcen Airport down from early 2021
Germany to extend coronavirus lockdown until March 28
Iran unveils data of imports, exports through Anzali port
Azerbaijan records notable growth in population's US dollar demand
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for March 2
Azerbaijani Association of Travel Agencies and Association of Travel Bloggers sign agreement of understanding (PHOTO)
Union ministers Amit Shah, S Jaishankar get Covid-19 vaccine after PM Modi
Azerbaijan to hold new auction for public property facilities
Azerbaijan in cooperation with Turkey to make movie about Karabakh War
TV, radio channels to be non-accredited for 2021 Formula 1 Azerbaijan Grand Prix
Iran's Changuleh - 'a very complex oil field', says official
Proven gas reserves not adequate to furnish rising demand
BHOS launches next ‘Business Education for Engineers’ course
Iran to build combined cycle power plan in Mazandaran Province
Azerbaijan confirms 143 more COVID-19 recoveries
Gold, silver prices down in Azerbaijan
Nitin Gadkari: Despite Covid, highway construction at a record of over 32 km a day
IAF To Take Part In Multinational Exercise "Desert Flag" With France, US In UAE
Uzbekistan reports increases in gasoline price
Uzbek ministry to purchase computer equipment via tender
Uzbek commodity exchange reports volume of RON-80 gasoline sold
Russia's Novak preparing for OPEC+ meeting on March 4
UK's European Technology Development Ltd interested in doing business in Turkmenistan
Iran discusses potential of power transmission lines to neighboring countries
Uzbek commodity exchange reports volume of goods sold for Feb. 22-28
Azerbaijan's Tax Service registers local affiliate of UAE's Masdar company
Azerbaijan shares data on mortgage and guaranteed loans issued over February 2021
Azerbaijan reveals amount of foreign currency bought by banks
Georgia shares details of state property privatized for symbolic price
F1 Azerbaijan Grand Prix 2021 to be hosted without spectators
F1 Azerbaijan Grand Prix to be held until 2024
Georgia reports 461 new cases of coronavirus for March 2
Failure to bring more barrels to trigger prices spiking beyond $70/bbl
Turkmenistan's State Enterprise opens tender to buy electrical equipment
European Investment Bank's loan reinforces support for recovery of Georgian MSMEs
Accreditation of journalists for 2021 Formula 1 Azerbaijan Grand Prix starts
All news