"Iran spy trial" in Saudi Arabia - mockery of justice, Human Rights Watch says

"Iran spy trial" in Saudi Arabia - mockery of justice, Human Rights Watch

Baku, Azerbaijan, May 18

By Khalid Kazimov - Trend:

Saudi Arabia's trial of 32 men for allegedly spying on behalf of Iran has violated the basic due process rights of the defendants, Human Rights Watch said.

Over nearly three years of detention and investigation and the first two months of hearings, authorities have not permitted defendants to meet with lawyers or provided all of the court documents necessary to prepare defense. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for 25 of the 32 people, Human Rights Watch reported May 17.

The men are accused of spying for Iran. But the charge sheet, which Human Rights Watch has reviewed, contains numerous allegations that do not resemble recognizable crimes, including "supporting demonstrations," "harming the reputation of the kingdom," and attempting to "spread the Shia confession." The trial began in February 2016 at the Specialized Criminal
Court in Riyadh.

"This trial is shaping up as another stain on Saudi Arabia's grossly unfair criminal justice system," said executive director of Human Rights Watch's Middle East and North Africa Division Sarah Leah Whitson. "Criminal trials should not be merely legal 'window-dressing' where the verdict has been decided beforehand."

According to the charge sheet, the defendants include 30 Saudis, and one Iranian and one Afghan citizen. An individual with direct knowledge of the case told Human Rights Watch that all but one of the Saudi defendants are Shia Muslims. Authorities detained 17 people on March 16, 2013, 14 others later in 2013, and one in 2014.

Taha al-Haji, a Saudi lawyer who represented a group of the defendants until March, told Human Rights Watch that the defendants have been in pre-trial detention since their arrests. He and another person with knowledge of the case said that authorities held the men incommunicado for three months before allowing phone calls and visits with family members.

Al-Haji said that authorities have not permitted defense lawyers to visit their clients or to view case files and evidence against their clients. He said that with little advance notice, the authorities suddenly brought the men to trial in February and demanded that lawyers prepare defense statements within two weeks.

He said he believes the timing may relate to ongoing hostility between Iran and Saudi Arabia, which severed diplomatic relations in January after Saudi Arabia executed a prominent Saudi Shia cleric, Nimr al-Nimr, and Iranian protesters sacked the Saudi embassy in Tehran in retaliation.

Local Saudi media outlets reported in March that some of the defense lawyers refused to participate in court proceedings. The Saudi Gazette, reported that "lawyers made a number of demands through some [defendants who attended the hearing], including providing them with car parking slots near the court, not to be frisked, and letting them in [the courtroom] with their
mobile phones."

Al-Haji said, however, that the lawyers' primary concerns have been an inability to visit clients and view evidence, or have adequate time to prepare a defense. He said defense lawyers also asked the court to halt an ongoing local media smear campaign against their clients, which they said would lead to an unfair trial.

The charge sheet includes a number of offenses constituting "high treason," including meeting with Iranian "intelligence agents" and passing them confidential military information and background information on Shia communities in Mecca, Medina, and Saudi Arabia's Eastern Province.

But among charges that do not represent recognizable crimes, six people are charged with "supporting demonstrations," three with "distorting the reputation of the kingdom," and three with attempting to "spread the Shia confession" in Saudi Arabia. One faces the charge of "planning with an Iranian intelligence element... to establish a company to spread Shia
activities in [Eastern Province.]..." Another faces the charge of "endeavoring and attempting to establish a center especially for the Shia confession in the city of Mecca to spread the Shia confession in Mecca."

Authorities accuse one defendant of sharing with Iranian intelligence agents "articles by the wayward and deviant thinker Mikhlif bin Daham al-Shammari." Al-Shammari is a prominent human rights defender in Saudi Arabia who has worked to improve relations between Sunni and Shia muslims. He faces a two-year prison sentence and 200 lashes for, in part, visiting prominent
Shia figures in the eastern province as a goodwill gesture.

Saudi Arabia's Shia citizens face systematic discrimination in public education, government employment, and permission to build houses of worship in the Sunni-dominated country.

Though defense lawyers have not been permitted access to evidence, the charge sheet makes reference to physical evidence, such as USB drives and computers as well as confessions and statements to investigators.

Human Rights Watch obtained and analyzed seven Specialized Criminal Court judgments from 2013 and 2014 against men and children accused of protest-related crimes following demonstrations by members of the Shia minority. In all seven trials, detainees alleged that confessions were extracted through torture, but judges quickly dismissed these allegations,
admitted the confessions as evidence, and then convicted the detainees almost solely based on these confessions, sometimes handing down death sentences.

The conduct of the trial so far raises fears that 25 of the 32 defendants could be handed death sentences without an adequate chance to defend themselves, Human Rights Watch said.

Article 13 of the Arab Charter on Human Rights, which Saudi Arabia ratified in 2009, guarantees the right to a fair trial. The Arab Charter also guarantees the right of anyone arrested or detained on a criminal charge to be brought promptly before a judge or other officer of the law, and to have a trial within a reasonable time or be released. The charter says that
"Pre-trial detention shall in no case be the general rule" (article 14).

Article 25 of the Arab Charter guarantees the right of minority groups to practice their own religion, and article 4 bans discrimination on the basis of religion.

"Being a Shia Muslim should not be a crime, and Saudi courts should stop treating it as such," Whitson said.

Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for October 20
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for October 20
Iran reveals amount of investments made on buying agricultural machinery
Iran reveals amount of investments made on buying agricultural machinery
Terminal on exports of agricultural goods to be built in Iran's Astara County
Terminal on exports of agricultural goods to be built in Iran's Astara County
Loading Bars
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for October 20
Speaker of Turkish Grand National Assembly visits Azerbaijan’s Ganja (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Georgia to export fresh pinecones to EU market
Azerbaijan increases export of petrochemicals
EIB supports construction of Innovation Center in Georgia
President Ilham Aliyev addressing the nation
Missile attacks on cities, its residents, civil objects inhuman - Kazakh ambassador in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijani servicemen contributing to victories of country's army (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani methanol plant unveils export indicators for 9M2020
Azerbaijani army destroys numerous Armenian servicemen, military equipment (VIDEO)
Review of producer price indices for services in Georgia
Azerbaijan records growth in gas exports
Export of confectionery products increase in Uzbekistan for 9M2020
Russia's leading research institute talks COVID-19 impact on Turkmenistan
Azerbaijan ups import of Turkish wood, furniture
Export of furniture, wood from Turkey to US more than doubles in 9M2020
Turkey's 9M2020 export of wood, furniture to Germany grows
Precious metal prices in Azerbaijan down
Enagas reveals investment plans for TAP
Kazakhstan's export to Ukraine down twofold amid COVID-19
Iran reveals amount of investments made on buying agricultural machinery
EU and Uzbekistan eye to expand scope of co-op
Armenia’s demographic challenges: Depopulation & Racist Policy
Turkmengas re-opens tender for maintenance of gas turbine compressors
Value of exports from Uzbekistan down for 92020
Armenia: Acquired investment deficit syndrome
Enagas sees over 4.5% increase in net profit
Terminal on exports of agricultural goods to be built in Iran's Astara County
Russian Gazprombank says Azerbaijani GDP dynamics in line with expectations
Territories of Azerbaijani Terter and Aghdam regions under fire
Armenia's dastardly crimes won’t go unpunished, says speaker of Azerbaijan's Parliament
Azerbaijani FM meets Turkish Parliament's speaker
Azerbaijani FM Bayramov to meet US Secretary of State Pompeo
Azerbaijani oil prices fluctuate
Georgia sees increase in PPI for Industrial Products
Azerbaijani Prosecutor General's Office gives updates on civil casualties, damages
Chairperson of Azerbaijan's parliament talks Turkish Grand National Assembly's support
Production of vehicles in Azerbaijan continues growth
Cargo transportation volumes decrease in Kazakhstan country-wide
Manufacturing enterprises launched in industrial parks of Iran's Qazvin Province
Carpet exports from Turkey to Uzbekistan decreased - Trade Ministry
Ukraine slightly reduces import of Turkish carpets
Kazakhmys made progress towards reducing its dependence on outward reinsurance - Fitch
Pakistan's imports of Turkish carpets down
Uzbekistan, S.Korea in talks over developing metal ore deposit in Uzbekistan’s Navoi
Turkey always next to Azerbaijan on int'l arena - parliament's chairman
After plenary session in Baku, Turkish Parliament's speaker leaves for Ganja
Balkan Department of Turkmenistan’s Construction Ministry exceeds production plan
OSCE MG shows no necessary will to resolve Karabakh conflict - Turkish Parliament speaker
Volume of market services in Uzbekistan up for 9M2020
Georgia reports 1,194 new coronavirus cases
Kazakhstan’s Ulba Metallurgical Plant to buy petroleum products via tender
Domestic Producer Price Index for Industrial Products up in Georgia
Iranian minister declares amount of revenues from sales of state-owned shares
Azerbaijan's Blasto CJSC wins tender opened by local mining company for exploration work
Kazakhstan's Air Astana opens tender to buy fuel
Azercell continues to support medical staff fighting coronavirus
Euronext's stock markets resume trading after previous day's glitches
Import Price Index up in Georgia
Georgia to resume regular flights to 10 more cities
Azerbaijan Army inflicting strikes at firing points of Armenian armed forces (VIDEO)
Damage to Azerbaijan's Ganja city from Armenian aggression revealed
Azerbaijani, Pakistani FMs hold phone conversation
Azerbaijan reveals production, retail sales volumes of ICT products for 9M2020
Armenia - source of threat to entire region, says Turkish parliament's chairman
Kazakhstan’s Air Astana reducing flights to Turkey, UAE, Ukraine and Germany
UK firms regularly send enquiries about energy projects in Azerbaijan
IMF announces forecast for Azerbaijani Central Bank's foreign exchange reserves
Uzbekistan's GDP up for 9M2020
IMF releases forecast of Azerbaijan's oil sector for 2020-2021
Kazakhstan's Tengiz field using technologies to keep employees away from high-risk areas
UAE government delegation heads to Israel for first official visit
Weekly review of Georgian capital markets
Russian power engineering company completes assembly of third hydroelectric unit of Uzbek HPP
Syrian tribes condemn Armenia's alliance with YPG Kurds
IMF forecasts growth of Azerbaijan's gas exports in coming years
UK Export Finance has scope to support solar projects in Azerbaijan - Baroness Nicholson
Export of carpets from Turkey to Turkmenistan decreased
Tajikistan significantly reduces import of carpets from Turkey
Armenia must be seated at negotiating table as occupying country - Azerbaijani MP (VIDEO)
Kazakhstan's improved financial system shows value during COVID-related crisis, says IMF
Turkmen company produces large volume of protective masks per day
New airline company to start operations in Georgia
COVID-19 situation in Azerbaijan will depend on citizens' compliance with recommendations - WHO
I’ve been horrified to see news of deadly attacks on Ganja, Terter, Beylagan - Baroness Nicholson
Azerbaijani scientist talks endemics destroyed by Armenians in occupied lands
Chevron to transform Penjuru Terminal in Singapore to smart terminal
Uzbekneftegaz reveals worth of products production for 2020
Leguminous crop being harvested in Turkmenistan’s Dashoguz region
Chevron using technology to raise well performance
Chevron implementing public 5G at one of its facilities
Iran’s CBI unveils amount of currency sold to exchange offices
Armenian Armed Forces replenished with terrorists from various countries - Turkish expert
Iranian currency rates for October 20
Azerbaijani currency rates for Oct. 20
Azerbaijani Environmental Public Council, Environmental Civil Society Organizations appeal to int'l organizations on Armenian aggression
Latest achievements of Azerbaijani army over Armenian forces
Iran's parliamentarians seek transparency in revenues
Turkmenistan announces terms of temporary import of vehicles into country
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for October 20
All news