MPs say no to EU referendum

Labour rebels were tonight defeated in their attempt to force the government to "keep a promise" to hold a referendum on the Lisbon treaty. ( Guardian )

But in an unexpected turn of events, a separate Tory amendment received virtually the same level of support as the Labour call for a referendum.

While the Labour amendment was defeated by a majority of 64 (311 against, 247 for), the Tory amendment was defeated by 63 votes (311 to 248).

To the embarrassment of Gordon Brown, the result suggests a number of Labour rebels backed the Tory bid to have a referendum, as well the one tabled by Ian Davidson, Labour MP for Glasgow South West.

While the Tory proposal favoured a straightforward referendum, Davidson's amendment set out measures to put in place a referendum on the Lisbon treaty and also allow the possibility of another referendum on Britain's membership of the European Union.

The results put to rest an issue which has caused bitter divisions within both the Labour and the Liberal Democrats.

MPs in both parties are uncomfortable with their leader's insistence that respective manifesto commitments to hold a referendum were null and void because the promise had been made on the basis of the constitution, not the EU treaty which replaced it after the constitution was abandoned.

About two dozen Labour MPs and 10 Liberal Democrats had been expected to defy their respective leaderships and vote in favour of a referendum, amid a series of polls which suggest widespread public support.

Speaking in the debate earlier today, Davidson told MPs they were "honour bound" to hold a referendum.

He said: "If we want to stop the disillusionment and cynicism about politics, we've got to recognizes that the people out there expect us to keep our promises when we make them and that's why, on this side of the House, I believe we are honour bound to abide by our commitment to a referendum."

But foreign secretary David Miliband said there were "big differences". The structure of the constitution abandoned all previous treaties that governed the EU, but the Lisbon Treaty did not,"he said.

"Secondly, in respect of a range of policies, notably on justice and home affairs, the content is different.

"Thirdly, in respect of the consequences, the constitutional treaty was alleged by many Tory MPs to be a slipway to a superstate.

"Under the Lisbon Treaty there is an agreement there shall be no further institutional reform for the foreseeable future.

"So in structure, and in content, and in consequence this is different."

In his first real test of leadership, Nick Clegg saw a number of Lib Dems defy a three line party whip to abstain on the amendments.

Three of his front bench are already believed to have quit their post to vote with the Tories for a referendum.

David Heath, the justice spokesman, Tim Farron, the countryside spokesman, and Alistair Carmichael, the Scotland and Northern Ireland spokesman, were among the most senior MPs to indicate they would rebel.

The referendum led to heated exchanges between the three party leaders at prime minister's question time earlier today.

Tory leader David Cameron, the Conservative leader, accused Brown of not supporting a referendum because he was worried he would lose it.

Pointing out that all three main political parties promised a referendum on the proposed EU constitution in their 2005 election manifestos, Cameron said: "A referendum was promised, it should be delivered. If Labour can't trust the people, why should the people trust Labour?"

But Brown insisted that the Lisbon treaty was different from the constitution. "If you want to persist in talking about the 'United States of Europe' and a constitutional treaty, you have no support in the rest of Europe," he told Cameron.

"If your party had really changed and moved to the centre, you would be standing up to your backbenchers - you would be leading them instead of following them.

"You would be standing up to the Eurosceptics instead of appeasing them. You would be moving to the centre of Europe instead of being left at the margins of Europe."

Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg said Mr Brown had "bottled" a referendum and said voters would not believe in the European Union until politicians were prepared to stand up for it.

Diesel prices increase in Kazakhstan year-on-year
Diesel prices increase in Kazakhstan year-on-year
Kazakhstan-based world's largest uranium producer talks 2020 operational forecasts
Kazakhstan-based world's largest uranium producer talks 2020 operational forecasts
Kazakhstan’s postal service operator to buy fuel via tender
Kazakhstan’s postal service operator to buy fuel via tender
Loading Bars
Latest
Another 78 oxygen concentrators delivered to Kyrgyz capital
Turkey's five-month export to EU lowers
PCR certification mandatory for Iraqis entering Iran
COVID-19 testing completed at Lilo Mall and Dinamo Market in Georgia
Coronavirus pandemic increases demand for private housing in suburbs of large cities in Georgia
TABIB: Issue of opening small outdoor cafes in Azerbaijan to be discussed
TABIB: Number of COVID-19 patients in hospitals decreases thanks to strict quarantine
Azerbaijan reveals number of COVID-19 tests carried out so far
Google unveils its first 5G phones, starting at $499
Speakers of Azerbaijani, Turkish parliaments have telephone conversation
Issue related to allowing trips to Azerbaijani districts under discussion
Azerbaijani cities, districts with extended quarantine restrictions disclosed - LIST
Italian specialists arrive in Azerbaijan as part of fight against coronavirus
TABIB: Worldwide work towards COVID-19 vaccine development in spotlight
Assistant to Azerbaijani president: UN special session may last 5-6 months, even year
Assistant to Azerbaijani president meets with members of Azerbaijani community of Nagorno-Karabakh region
Assistant to Azerbaijani president: Resumption of subway, shopping centers activities could lead to COVID-19 cases increase
Assistant to Azerbaijan's president talks new possible social support measures during COVID-19
Azerbaijan Finance Ministry recalculates budget parameters for current year
Georgian Airways to launch Tbilisi-Batumi flights
Uzbekistan's tourism ambassador: Catering sector promising for foreign investors
Hikmat Hajiyev: Azerbaijan following COVID-19 vaccine dev't process
Flights between Azerbaijan, foreign countries planned to be opened
Assistant to President: There's positive dynamics in fighting COVID-19 in Azerbaijan
Ministry: Georgia receives good harvest of potato
Azerbaijan to apply toughened special quarantine regime in one more district
Azerbaijan discloses restrictions remaining in force during quarantine regime
Diesel prices increase in Kazakhstan year-on-year
Azerbaijan reports 647 new COVID-19 recoveries
World Bank's tourism development consultant talks future of tourism in Uzbekistan
Restrictions on public transport to remain in some cities, districts of Azerbaijan
Turkey's General Directorate of State Airports Authority opens tender to purchase fuel
Weekly review of Georgian capital market
Turkmenistan discloses volume of potatoes harvested in Dashoguz region
Azerbaijan discloses country's 1H2020 currency reserves
Azerbaijani association talks impact of COVID-19 on production of sand, gravel, stone
Rules on empty home tax to apply to Iran's cities with population over 100,000
Operational Headquarters makes decision to mitigate quarantine regime in Azerbaijan
Another resident registered at Azerbaijan's Sumgayit Chemical Industrial Park
Armenian side creates fake Twitter account in name of Azerbaijan's Defense Ministry
Operational Headquarters under Azerbaijani Cabinet of Ministers cancels permission for leaving home via SMS
Azerbaijan discloses rules for visiting beaches during quarantine regime
Georgia increases export of peaches, nectarines
Volume of foreign currency transactions at Turkmen State Commodity Exchange revealed
Volume of cargo transshipment through Turkish Aliaga port in 1H2020 disclosed
How “friendship” for money let Armenia down
Uzbek-Korean JV opens tender to buy batteries
Azerbaijan, US expand agricultural cooperation
Uzbek bank invests at London Stock Exchange
MP: Azerbaijani army fully equipped, has powerful staff potential (VIDEO)
Heritage Foundation talks necessary measures to improve Turkmenistan’s energy sector
Coronavirus situation under control in Iran - Rouhani
ADB to help strengthen health system of Uzbekistan
Georgian Credo Bank, EIB sign finance agreement to support MSMEs in Georgia
Uzbekistan increases cotton oil production
Turkmen Ministry opens tender for construction of facilities
Wall Street Journal publishes article criticizing double standards of Human Rights Watch
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for August 3
Kazakhstan-based world's largest uranium producer talks 2020 operational forecasts
Turkmenistan reveals volume of natural gas supplied to China
Kazakhstan’s postal service operator to buy fuel via tender
SHELL & TURCAS PETROL reduces sales of petroleum products
Iran aims to increase steel production
Rouhani: Iran's economic strategy to be realistic
Iran stock index breaks new record
Int'l Road Transport Union supports transport infrastructure digitalization in Uzbekistan
Georgia's Batumi sees decrease in real estate transactions
Azerbaijani Consulate General in US' LA sends letter of protest to UFC President
German Lufthansa resumes regular flights to Georgia
Turkmenistan imports various types of textile products from EAEU countries
Uzbekistan aims to complete construction of first GTL plant in 2020 despite pandemic
ADB highlights four key areas that can help Uzbekistan to recover its economy
Kazakhstan's uranium production down year-on-year amid COVID-19 pandemic
Export from Turkey to Turkic-speaking countries shows uptick in 1H2020
Colliers International: Number of apartment transactions in Georgian Tbilisi decreases
Equinor reduces production from Azeri-Chirag-Gunashli
Refining volumes down in Kazakhstan due to COVID-19 quarantine measures
Turkey's six-month export to D-8 countries drops
Turkmenistan imports large volume of polymer from Russia
IRU ready to help Uzbekistan create intermodal corridor with Afghanistan, Iran
Geostat reveals Georgia's inflation rate in July 2020
Kazakhstan's Air Astana to buy fuel via tender
Turkey's export to BSEC countries down in 1H2020
Central Bank of Uzbekistan sets currency rates for August 4–August 11
Large volume of sugar products imported to Turkmenistan
Another batch of Azerbaijani oil sent for Belarus
Uzbekistan completing modernization of Mubarek Gas Processing Plant
Kazakhstan’s Almaty Power Stations JSC opens tender to buy transformers
Export from Turkey to OIC member countries lowers in 1H2020
No obstacles for development of Tehran-Baku economic relations
Azerbaijani greenhouses, cooling rooms to be registered online
Kazakhstan's national oil company faces oil transportation declines
Bulgarian gas imports from Azerbaijan may be increased after 2025
TAP to allow Greek DEPA to cut off BOTAS contract supplies
Turkmenistan’s chemical plant increases its production
Kazakhstan, India mutual trade triples despite COVID-19
Azerbaijani oil prices (July 27-31)
Uzbekistan's import of brazilian raw cane sugar shrinks
Central Bank of Uzbekistan reviews dynamics of national currency exchange rate
Eni lowers capital budget by 35%
All news