China still has trouble reading Tibet's pulse

When China allowed envoys of the exiled Dalai Lama to visit Tibet in the early 1980s as part of a cautious detente, Communist Party cadres told residents not to stone or spit at their one-time masters. ( Reuters )

But the officials were dumbfounded, and disconcerted, by what they saw: residents in Tibet's capital Lhasa mobbed the envoys, kneeling, crying and clutching their clothing to air grievances.

The incident underlined the inability, or unwillingness, of the Party to comprehend Tibetans and their reverence for their god-king, which analysts say remains the Achilles' heel of China's Tibet policy.

This month, the Communist Party again showed that it was out of touch with popular sentiment in the pious Himalayan region when monk-led protests suddenly erupted in Lhasa and spilled over into Chinese provinces populated by Tibetans.

"The problem is that in the Party, they delude themselves by thinking that Tibetans don't have legitimate grievances," Tsering Shakya, a Tibet scholar at the University of British Columbia, said in a telephone interview.

China has sought to win the hearts and minds of Tibetans by investing heavily in infrastructure and sees Tibetans as "ungrateful natives", Tsering Shakya said.

A Chinese source familiar with the government's Tibet policy said: "The central government invests billions (of yuan) in Tibet each year hoping for stability in return."

"But money cannot buy stability," the source told Reuters, requesting anonymity.

The recent unrest is perhaps an omen that the Tibet issue - an emotive one for many Westerners from the U.S. Congress to Hollywood - will overshadow the Beijing Olympics with protests likely to plague the international leg of the torch relay.

Many Tibetans complain their religious rights are clipped and that their culture is being slowly snuffed out. China's diatribes against the Dalai Lama also go down poorly.

The flare-up could be a turning point, as the region has a history of violent resistance against Chinese rule.

Tibetan guerrillas, funded and trained by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, ambushed and killed many Chinese soldiers in the 1960s. Fighting ending a decade later when the CIA pulled the plug after then president Richard Nixon's landmark 1972 visit to China.

Today, about 1,000 exiled Tibetans are serving in the Indian army, and there is no guarantee they would not return to guerrilla warfare if the Dalai Lama was to die without resolving remaining problems, analysts said.

China might eventually face a threat from radicalised Tibetans who reject the 1989 Nobel Peace Prize winner's peaceful "middle way", some say.

"The Dalai Lama is the key to the Tibet issue. He can either lock or unlock it," Wang Lixiong, who has visited Tibet about 20 times and written three books on the mountain region.

Tibetan youth have become increasingly impatient with the Dalai Lama's opposition to violence and advocacy of autonomy rather than independence.

"The lack of substantial progress undermines moderates in Tibet and gives hardliners a bigger say," Wang said.

The Dalai Lama might be the sole restraint on radicalisation of about 110,000 exiled Tibetans, analysts said.

Still, Tibet's hardline Communist Party boss Zhang Qingli is struggling for political survival after the worst unrest in two decades occurred under his watch. He has opted to blame the Dalai Lama and his supporters for plotting the unrest.

Zhang would be the last to admit that his repressive policies, such as forcing monks to undergo re-education and denouncing the Dalai Lama, might have actually helped spark the revolt.

Zhang even went as far as to say the Party was a "living Buddha", no doubt offending many in the region. The opening of a railway linking Tibet with the rest of China in 2006 has drawn criticism from international rights groups.

China's confidence that materialism would erode Tibetans' loyalty to the Dalai Lama was dented when many heeded his call not to wear endangered animal furs and burned prized skins.

Some analysts said it might be tough now for President Hu Jintao, who lacks the clout of his revolutionary forebears, to extend an olive branch to the Dalai Lama even if he wanted to.

But Hu is no stranger to seizing opportunity from crisis. He turned the tables during the SARS outbreak in 2003 and China came clean on reporting the epidemic. Hu has also undone many of his predecessor's policies, mending fences with Taiwan and Japan.

Hu would have to persuade hawks in more than 10 ministry-level agencies who have an interest in keeping the Dalai Lama out - including the provincial governments of Tibet and nearby Qinghai, Gansu, Sichuan and Yunnan.

Ultimately, there are unlikely to be winners in this month's unrest.

China has waged a smear campaign against the Dalai Lama and his supporters but few outside China are convinced. Prime Minister Gordon Brown will go ahead and meet the Buddhist monk when he visits Britain in May.

"He's a voice for moderation, he's very respected, he's sincere in his desire to see the Tibetan issue resolved," Minxin Pei, director of the China Programme at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said of the Dalai Lama.

"The Dalai Lama ought to be a partner, rather than an adversary," Pei added.

Weekly actual topics in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Weekly actual topics in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Weekly tenders in the region (April 16-20)
Weekly tenders in the region (April 16-20)
Last week’s laws, orders and decrees in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Last week’s laws, orders and decrees in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Loading Bars
Latest
Turkey confirms 13,604 new COVID-19 cases
Kyrgyzstan introduces state regulation of prices for vegetable oil and sugar
Immunization Technical Advisers of Georgia hope WHO to authorize Sinovac
Envoy: Iran supports Afghan peace process
TRACECA Permanent Representative talks cargo traffic growth on Azerbaijani section
Over 610 Palestinians injured in clashes with Israeli police in East Jerusalem - newspaper
Some 20 terrorists killed, 4 bases destroyed in Burkina Faso
WHO records over 677,000 new daily cases of COVID-19 worldwide
Italy reports just over 5,000 new COVID-19 cases, 198 deaths
7 rockets fired from Gaza at Jerusalem area: Israeli military
Saudi Arabia to require arriving visitors to quarantine for a week
Oil prices inch higher as traders eye U.S. pipeline shutdown
Palestinians report several killed in Israeli air raids on Gaza
Biden confident he will meet with Putin
Over 1.6mln receive COVID-19 vaccine in Kazakhstan
Azerbaijan's import of cars from Turkey drops
Iran makes advanced industrial flame arrester
Putin says 21.5 mln Russians vaccinated against COVID-19
U.S. Treasury launches access to $350 billion in state/local COVID-19 aid
President Ilham Aliyev receives delegation led by Russian foreign minister (PHOTO)
Global COVID-19 cases, deaths reach plateau - WHO
Electric, hybrid car sales in Turkey surge over 200% in 4 months
Georgian, North Macedonian Presidents sign visa-free agreement
Second component of Sputnik V vaccine delivered to Kyrgyzstan
Iran produces oil-based ozone generator
India COVID cases hold close to record highs as calls widen for national lockdown
USAID’s focus to remain on modernization of energy sector in Kazakhstan
China-made meteorological satellite for dawn-dusk orbit passes review
Saudi Arabia's GDP contracts 3.3% in Q1 on oil output, non-oil economy recovers
Azerbaijan purchasing new equipment to speed up mine clearance on liberated lands (VIDEO)
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on May 11
Weekly review of Azerbaijani precious metals market
Activities in Iran’s Khorramshahr port climb
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to increase
New facility to be put into operation in Iran’s electricity sector
Iran boosts production, export of greens and vegetables
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 10
Iran's ICOFC to develop two gas fields
National leader Heydar Aliyev`s 98th anniversary marked at parliament (PHOTO)
Program of Russian FM's visit to Azerbaijan unveiled
Azerbaijan confirms 371 more COVID-19 cases, 892 recoveries
Public reps of Azerbaijan paying tribute to late National Leader Heydar Aliyev (PHOTO)
Mine-clearing operations begin in Azerbaijan's liberated villages
Iran talks IAEA monitoring cameras at nuclear sites
Presidents of Russia, Azerbaijan hold phone conversation
Int'l organizations notified about Armenia's crimes against Azerbaijani civilians - Azerbaijan's prosecutor general
Criminal cases against Armenian terrorists who fought in Karabakh nearing completion - Prosecutor General of Azerbaijan
Uzbekistan eyes ratifying two more conventions of International Labor Organization
Uzbek mining and metallurgical complex exceeds export plan by half
Cargo movements in Iran’s Imam Khomeini port up
Iran reveals details of saffron exports
Various results achieved in Vienna every day – Iran’s MFA
Oil gains after cyberattack forces shutdown of U.S. fuel pipelines
Heydar Aliyev saved independent Azerbaijan from disappearing from political map - Russian expert
Iran, Saudi Arabia conduct both bilateral, regional talks – Iran's MFA
Registration of presidential candidates starts in Iran
Volume of loaded, unloaded cargo in Iranian ports grows
President Ilham Aliyev ends visit to Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan notes significant increase in bank cash turnover in 4M2021
Uzbekneftegaz reveals indicators of oil and gas production and processing in 4M2021
Uzbekistan and France sign cooperation program
Uzbekistan Helicopters LLC opens tender for refueling vehicle
Political will of Heydar Aliyev bearing fruit - colonel general
Carbon price to rise, as governments pursue deeper decarbonisation strategies
Iran expects to increase vaccination
President Ilham Aliyev interviewed by Azerbaijan Television (PHOTO)
Death toll from COVID-19 exceeds 75,000 people
Number of confirmed coronavirus cases in Russia rises by 8,465 per day
President Ilham Aliyev views Ordubad railway station (PHOTO)
President Aliyev attends launch of project for reconstruction of drinking water supply, sewerage systems in Ordubad (PHOTO)
President Ilham Aliyev views construction of Ordubad Hydroelectric Power Plant (PHOTO)
ERIELL to work on wells at field in Uzbekistan’s Karakalpakstan
First Vice President of Azerbaijan shares publication on occasion of 98th anniversary of birth of National Leader Heydar Aliyev
President Ilham Aliyev attends inauguration of Julfa-Ordubad highway (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan’s 1Q2021 tomatoes export revealed
Turkey sees increase in cement exports to Azerbaijan
Kazakhstan-Israel trade plummets y-o-y
Uzbekistan to connect number of small industrial zones to utility networks
Weekly review of Azerbaijani currency market
ACG oil transshipment from Ceyhan terminal exceeds 70 mb YTD
EBRD, EIB, Proparco to fund construction of solar power plant in Uzbekistan’s Samarkand
President Ilham Aliyev attends opening of Artificial Insemination Center in Nakhchivan (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan creating 'green' energy zone in liberated Karabakh
President Ilham Aliyev attends opening of Nakhchivan Garrison Central Hospital (PHOTO)
President Ilham Aliyev attended inauguration of Nakhchivan branch of “Azerkhalcha” OJSC (PHOTO)
Weekly review of Azerbaijani oil market
Bank of Israel cuts government bond purchases
President Ilham Aliyev viewed construction of “ASAN xidmət” Center in Nakhchivan (PHOTO)
Turkey's 4M2021 steel exports to Turkmenistan shrink
Armenian Parliament to reconsider issue of electing new prime minister
Iran increases sturgeon farming
World's largest cargo plane with UK Covid aid takes off for India
President Ilham Aliyev visits statue of national leader Heydar Aliyev in Nakhchivan (PHOTO)
India to recruit 400 retired medical officers of AMC, SSC; Defence Ministry issues orders
Iran eyes to expand ties Turkmenistan
Azerbaijani president visits graves of martyrs of Patriotic War at Nakhchivan city cemetery (PHOTO)
Indian-Led Ground-Breaking Cancer Test Hopes To Launch This Year
President Aliyev attends opening of military aerodrome of Special Combined Arms Army (PHOTO)
Iran to renovate public transport fleet
Iranian water and electricity companies to enter EAEU market
All news