WTO rules on huge plane dispute

WTO rules on huge plane dispute

The World Trade Organization (WTO) has given its long-awaited ruling on the biggest trade dispute in its history, BBC reported.

The decision, which is officially confidential, is over whether the European Union gave illegal subsidies to planemaker Airbus as the US argues.

The Wall Street Journal and others reported that the WTO had found in favour of the US position.

But a UK government source told the BBC that the WTO verdict was much more of a "mixed outcome".

"The decision really questions the wisdom of taking this to the WTO in the first place," the UK source said.

"Boeing will be far from jubilant tonight."

Both US and European diplomats have declined to officially release the ruling, which is more than 1,000 pages long.

The decision is not expected to be officially made public for at least several months.

Partially upheld?

The EU has also made a counter claim against the US for its support of Boeing. A ruling on the EU's claim against the US is due in the next six to eight months.

The ruling on Airbus comes after five years of deliberations.

Other US news reports had suggested that subsidies from Brussels were illegal under world trade rules.

US Representative Norm Dicks, who was briefed by US trade officials, told the Associated Press that the WTO ruling confirms the original complaint by the U.S. from 2004.

"For many years we have contended that direct financial assistance from the European governmental partners of Airbus has represented an unfair launch subsidy that has allowed Airbus to increase its market share in the large civil aircraft market and to steal US aircraft manufacturing jobs," he said.

"Today's interim ruling from the WTO panel definitively confirms that contention."

Mr Dicks representatives the US state of Washington, where Boeing is based.

But the UK government source told the BBC said the verdict did not suggest that the EU had engaged in systematic aid to Airbus.

Aid given by the EU to the European aircraft maker for its A350 aircraft was not cited, for example, the source said.

'Good case'

Experts say the WTO's decision will set the boundaries for acceptable government funding in civil aviation.

But Howard Wheeldon, senior strategist at BGC Partners, said there was still a long way to go in the saga.

"This whole WTO process is going to last four to five years. It's going to be 2013 at least before we get a final settlement on this," he said.

He added that Boeing and Airbus have to find terms so that they can work together based on what the WTO actually rules.

Louis Gallois, the chief executive of Airbus's parent company EADS, said before the decision that he believes the company has a "very good case".

LUKOIL optimistic about prospects for co-op with Turkmenistan
LUKOIL optimistic about prospects for co-op with Turkmenistan
Turkmenistan organizes charter flight from Russia’s Tatarstan amid COVID-19
Turkmenistan organizes charter flight from Russia’s Tatarstan amid COVID-19
Turkmenistan remains main gas exporter to China
Turkmenistan remains main gas exporter to China
Loading Bars
Latest
National Bank of Georgia sells funds at foreign exchange auction
World will lose heavily from enmity with Turkey and Azerbaijan, Turkish top official on Trend's 'Baku-Istanbul' teleconference ((PHOTO/VIDEO)
Discussions related to durable resolution of Karabakh conflict ongoing constantly - OSCE (Exclusive)
CNPC Drilling Company in Turkmenistan opens tender to buy electric batteries
Number of high-ranking Armenian officials dismissed from their posts within month
One more Azerbaijani civilian killed by Armenian Armed Forces - top official
Azerbaijan sharply increases import of eggs from Georgia
Lebanese human rights defenders condemn Armenian vandalism in Beirut
Armenia once again violates ceasefire agreements - FACTS
Azerbaijan increases tea imports from Georgia
VTB Bank Kazakhstan's parent bank expected to facilitate bank's growth plans for 2020-2021
Azerbaijan appeals to UNICEF regarding Armenia's terror against Barda's civilians
Facebook gains court backing in document row with EU regulators
Commissioning of desalination plant in Kazakhstan's semi-desert zone postponed
Number of debit cards in Azerbaijan continues to grow
Georgia reduces imports of construction materials from Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan reduces import of cigarettes from Georgia
Residents of Barda fully confident in Azerbaijani army - Executive authority
Georgia increases oil import from Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan reveals details of casualties, injuries in Tartar inflicted by Armenian troops
Electricity production using renewable energy sources increases in Kazakhstan
Azerbaijan increases import of passenger cars from Georgia
Kazakhstan decreases imports from Austria
Precious metal prices in Azerbaijan down
Austria interested in further promoting economic co-op with Turkmenistan
People like Vladimir Yevseev call on Armenia to commit war crimes - Israeli expert
Ronaldinho films video message in support of Azerbaijan
Missile-hit area of Azerbaijan's Barda city targeted purposefully - Executive Office
Armenian military-political leadership to be punished soon – Azerbaijani prosecutor general
Kazakhstan, Spain trade down nearly threefold amid COVID-19
Bashkortostan boosts fuel export to Uzbekistan
President Ilham Aliyev calls President Recep Tayyip Erdogan
Azerbaijan confirms 483 more COVID-19 recoveries
Small industrial zone to be created in Uzbekistan’s Tashkent
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva congratulates brotherly people of Turkey on 29 October-Republic Day
Kazakhstan, Austria agree on Action Plan of Kazakhstan-Austrian Business Council for 2021
Armenian leadership shelled Tartar ignoring visit of diplomats - President's aide
Azerbaijani currency rates for Oct. 29
China's premium car buyers drive VW back to profit
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for October 29
Kraft Heinz third-quarter sales beat estimates
Bahar Azadi gold coin price again rising in Iran
Georgia has record high grape harvest in past 30 years
Int'l journalist sends Letter to Joe Biden in regards to his statement on Karabakh
Armenia shells Goygol district, fire breaks out in forest - Ministry of Emergency Situations
Joint technical committee to be set up related to Khudafarin & Giz Galasi hydro junctions
ADB approves loan to support Georgia’s economic recovery
Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan increases value of its agricultural production
Turkmenistan plans to increase natural gas supplies to China
Armenian servicemen, who fire at civilians in Azerbaijan’s Barda, killed on battlefield (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan shoots down two Su-25 of Armenia – Defense ministry
Aircraft of Azerbaijani Armed Forces not involved in today's battles - Defense Ministry
Turkish Airlines to launch multiple charter flights to Georgia
Georgia's economic growth rate to up
Armenia used cluster bombs prohibited by all int'l conventions to attack civilians in Barda - Assistant to First Vice President of Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan’s all Smerch multiple rocket launchers fully operational – Defense ministry
Azerbaijan's Zangilan city liberated not long before 27-year anniversary of its occupation
Azerbaijan hands over bodies of soldiers, captured civilians to Armenia - president's aide
Azerbaijan bombing maternity hospital in Nagorno-Karabakh's Khankendi - fake
Top Iranian cleric condemns Armenia killing innocents in Azerbaijan's Barda city
Azerbaijan to become regional leader in energy efficiency - EU4Energy manager
Assessment of Turkmenistan's hydrocarbon resources published
Barda is beautiful and strong with reinforced determination - top official
Azerbaijani MPs to observe parliamentary elections in Georgia
Georgian vegetable oil company Qarva expanding its business
Assistant to Azerbaijani president, foreign diplomats visit Tartar
Kazakh-Chinese bitumen plant opens tender to buy electric materials
Neighboring countries increase demand to buy subsidized Iranian products
IFRC president makes statement on death of volunteer following Armenia's Barda shelling
Azerbaijan gives update on civil casualties, damages, following Armenia's attacks
Eni’s capex almost halves year-on-year
Criminal case opened on fact of Armenia's missile attack on Azerbaijan's Barda
Destroying historical monuments in Karabakh - against cultural identity of Azerbaijanis
Azerbaijani prosecutor general discloses number of victims of Armenian terror
OSCE MG either unable or uwilling to solve Karabakh conflict - Erdogan
IFRC Europe Office makes statement on Azerbaijani volunteer killed as result of Armenian shelling
Launch process for water and electricity facilities in Iran continues
Azerbaijani Armed Forces driving away Armenian troops like dogs – Assistant to president
Armenian Armed Forces cowardly flee from battlefield – Assistant to Azerbaijani president
Kazakhstan’s Intergas Central Asia opens tender for equipment maintenance
Generation capacity Iran's power plants grows
Armenia hostile to entire Islamic world, says Algerian analyst
LUKOIL optimistic about prospects for co-op with Turkmenistan
Heavily injured in Armenia's attack on Azerbaijan's Barda, brought to Baku
Azerbaijani FM’s visit to Geneva postponed
Foreign diplomats arrive in Barda, which is still under fire by Armenian troops (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan condemns publication of Charlie Hebdo about Turkish president - Assistant to Azerbaijani president
Azerbaijani oil prices decrease
New refrigeration facility for food opens in Georgia's Kakheti region
To liberate occupied lands, Azerbaijani Army striking military targets, but without harming civilians - MoD
Eni increases natural gas production at its Kazakhstan-based fields
Winter wheat planting completed in Turkmenistan’s Akhal region
Armenian leadership to be held accountable - Prosecutor General (PHOTO)
Loans to entrepreneurs increased in Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan
ANAMA reveals details of Armenian attacks on Azerbaijan's Barda
Central Banks of Iran announces volume of foreign currency put up for sale
Assistant to Azerbaijani President arrives in Barda, Tartar together with diplomatic corps (PHOTO)
Foreign exchange reserves of Azerbaijan's CB increase
Ambassador of France in Azerbaijan makes statement on Armenian missile attack on Barda
Industrial production increased in Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic
All news