Ariel Cohen: Parallels between referendum in South Sudan and situation around Nagorno-Karabakh misplaced

Ariel Cohen: Parallels between referendum in South Sudan and situation around Nagorno-Karabakh misplaced

Azerbaijan, Baku, Jan. 18 / Trend E.Tariverdiyeva /

Situation in the East Timor and South Sudan are very different from the events in the South Caucasus and cannot be compared with the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict or used as a model in this case, the Heritage Foundation's leading expert on Eurasia and Trend Expert Council member Ariel Cohen said.

CIS Institute Armenian Branch Head Alexander Makarov compared the actions of Yerevan, which occupied the Nagorno-Karabakh and seven surrounding regions of Azerbaijan, with the ongoing process of self-determination of South Sudan and East Timor. "A referendum in Nagorno-Karabakh was held 19 years ago, and recent years have shown that Azerbaijan has no rights in respect of Karabakh," he said at the news conference.  

The referendum in South Sudan is a classic self-determination under the legal framework. The key point of such a determination is that the referendum was agreed in the Comprehensive Peace Agreement dated Jan. 9, 2005 between the central government and the South.

Sudan is Africa's largest country with a population of 38 million and an area of 2,500,000 square kilometers. Holding a referendum on self-determination of South Sudan has become possible after the peace agreement reached in 2005 between the government and the Sudan People's Liberation Movement leading fight against it in the south. This agreement ended the civil war lasting for years. Up to 2010, 2 million people become the victims of the war and 4 million more became refugees.

Cohen said the United Nations has passed 4 resolutions and clearly expressed its opinion on the pathways to resolution of the Karabakh crisis. So did the chairmen of the OSCE Minsk Group.

"They adjudicated that Armenia needs to relinquish the occupation and allow refugees to return to their homes," he wrote Trend in an e-mail.

"Azerbaijan has promised far reaching concessions, including accepting the liberation of the Azerbaijani districts in Lachin Corridor first and liberation of Karabakh proper later, including a future referendum regarding the final status of Karabakh," he said.

Clearly, Cohen said, the East Timor and South Sudan are very different from the events in the South Caucasus and cannot be compared or used as a model in this case.

The conflict between the two South Caucasus countries began in 1988 when Armenia made territorial claims against Azerbaijan. Armenian armed forces have occupied 20 percent of Azerbaijan since 1992, including the Nagorno-Karabakh region and 7 surrounding districts.

Azerbaijan and Armenia signed a ceasefire agreement in 1994. The co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group - Russia, France, and the U.S. - are currently holding the peace negotiations.

Armenia has not yet implemented the U.N. Security Council's four resolutions on the liberation of the Nagorno-Karabakh and the surrounding regions.

Araghchi arrives in Vienna to attend 4th round of JCPOA talks
Araghchi arrives in Vienna to attend 4th round of JCPOA talks
Main part of Iran's trade carried out by sea - analyst
Main part of Iran's trade carried out by sea - analyst
Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds in Iran
Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds in Iran
Loading Bars
Latest
GM posts strong performance in Q1
Bundestag approves easing of COVID-19 rules for immunized people
Diamond demand in China directly benefits Botswana: De Beers
U.S. weekly jobless claims drop to 498,000, marking new low during pandemic
WHO says COVID-19 vaccine supply hitches could reignite upticks in Africa
Food prices continue to climb in April - FAO
Turkey reports over 22 388 COVID-19 cases
At least 23 killed in Rio de Janeiro favela gun battle
Kyrgyzstan is interested in establishing joint Kyrgyz-Korean enterprises
Turkey's 1Q2021 revenues from car export to int'l market grow
We reject, don't recognize decision of Latvian gov't on so-called "Armenian genocide" - Turkish Defense Ministry
Georgia launches campaign to popularize state agricultural insurance program
New “Azerbaijan” Ro-Pax ship built in country’s shipyard to make its first voyage from Port of Baku (PHOTO/VİDEO)
Former Maldives president hurt in blast outside home
Turkey’s inactive COVID-19 vaccine makes it to WHO list
Saudi Arabia showing interest in importing Azerbaijan's AzGranata products
Araghchi arrives in Vienna to attend 4th round of JCPOA talks
Kazakhstan - Greece trade down y-o-y
Georgian banks see profit in 1Q2021
Azerbaijan’s Azerishig company opens tender to buy various combined, storage accessories
Uzbek TPP to use German equipment for energy production
Azerbaijani national team holds podium training for upcoming Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup in Baku (VIDEO)
International Bank of Azerbaijan opens tender to buy Cisco network switches
Kazakhstan, Russia lift mutual restrictions on import, transit of livestock products
World auto concerns’ production volume to decrease during 6M2021
OSCE Chairperson-in-Office welcomes release of Armenian detainees by Azerbaijan
Greece decreases petroleum oil exports from Kazakhstan
Sputnik Light vaccine can be used for people aged 18-60
Moderna booster increases antibodies against COVID-19 variants, early data shows
Azerbaijan names amount of subsidies paid out for cropping
Yerevan ready to exert all efforts to fulfill trilateral agreements on Karabakh - acting PM of Armenia
Lebanon could gradually go dark as cash for electricity runs out
New greenhouse to be built in Turkmenistan’s Mary region
Several digitalization projects implemented in Kazakh oil & gas sector
Kazakhstan's president decides to provide humanitarian aid to Kyrgyzstan
Real estate purchases soar in Kazakhstan
Saudi Arabia eyes importing finished meat products from Uzbekistan
Azerbaijan's non-oil exports show positive trend despite impact of COVID-19 - minister
Kazakh Kazgeology eyes working on promising areas of natural resources
Main part of Iran's trade carried out by sea - analyst
Israel and Korea to sign free trade agreement next week
EU continues to support Georgia SMEs
Azerbaijan launches system for predicting impact of tax benefits on state revenues
Azerbaijan's AzFina, CBA developing bill on regulation of payment systems
Georgia's minister claims inflation in country to decrease in coming months
Kazakhstan reports increase in oil, natural gas prices
Azerbaijan may change procedure for navigation on inland waters for fishing vessels
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 6
Construction of Ahmadbayli-Fuzuli-Shusha highway in Azerbaijan continues (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan confirms 844 more COVID-19 cases, 2,057 recoveries
Uzbek-Korean JV to buy power cables via tender
Kazakh-Georgian Economic Union to focus on int'l trade and dev't of transport services - Honorary Consul
First section of Georgian Rikoti Highway to open soon
Kazakh IT company involved in creation of "smart" settlements in Azerbaijan
Japanese TEPSCO to join creating green energy zone in Azerbaijan's liberated territories
Azerbaijan's Mine Action Agency eyes to purchase new mine clearance equipment
Uzbek-Korean JV opens tender for construction of security facility for gas treatment
Turkmen Ministry of Construction extends tender for design of buildings
Georgia to host annual meeting of ADB board of governors
Spain tourist arrivals slump 76% in March, recovery still far off
Azerbaijan's construction sector output to grow till 2026 - expert
Trade ministry discloses volume of cereals imported by Austria from Turkey
Share of mining sector in Baku's industrial production disclosed
Amazing opportunities created for athletes in Baku’s National Gymnastics Arena - Ukrainian Gymnastics Federation
Turkmengas opens tender for purchase of chemicals
Kazakhstan's National Bank unveils preliminary balance of payments data
Statistics on trade turnover between Spain, Turkmenistan revealed
Uzbekistan receives permission to export pomegranates to China
Moderna raises 2021 sales forecast for COVID-19 vaccine to $19.2 billion
Not calling released soldiers as "POWs" by OSCE Minsk Group - outrageous - Armenian media
Tesla developing platform to allow car owners in China data access
Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds in Iran
Over 10 mln COVID-19 vaccine doses administered in Saudi Arabia
Russia reports over 7,600 COVID-19 cases in the past day
Revanchist statements in Armenia mustn't be taken seriously - Azerbaijani Security Council
Precious metal prices in Azerbaijan fluctuate
No reason to worry about fulfillment of trilateral statement - Azerbaijan's Security Council
Nominations for gas flows at TAP’s interconnections
Azerbaijan to build road to legendary "Isa Spring" in Shusha city
EU countries agree to open up to Israeli tourists
Turkmenistan names data on deposits in credit institutions
Iran unveils volume of transit through Gilan Province
Largest share of Uzbek textile production falls on Fergana region
Turkey boosts export of cars to Kazakhstan
Turkey publishes data on 4M2021 steel exports
Iran's Amir-Kabir Petrochemical Company beats sets new production record
Turkey's 4M2021 exports of locally-made furniture up in value
Turkey reveals 4M2021 data on export of grains, legumes to Azerbaijan
Exports through Iran's Astara border checkpoint increase
Uzbekistan to launch several TPPs in 2021
Uzbek agency reveals data on most profitable companies
ADB approves loan for construction of Georgia’s Olympic swimming pool
Georgia in talks with Johnson & Johnson and Novavax to receive vaccines
Georgian ISET-PI shares pricing on residential real estate in Tbilisi
Georgian Pension Agency shares data on pension fund's assets
Uzbekistan reveals number of vaccinated people
Kazakh uranium extracting company opens tender to buy spares
Kazakhstan decreases trade with Canada amid COVID-19
China increases import of Turkish-made cars
Turkey reveals 1Q2021 data on cargo movement via local ports from Belgium
All news